>>Good afternoon from the Venetian Expo, center, hall, whatever you wanna call it, in Las Vegas. Lisa Martin here. It's day four. I'm not sure what this place is called. Wait, >>What? >>Lisa Martin here with Dave Ante. This is the cube. This is day four of a ton of coverage that we've been delivering to you, which, you know, cause you've been watching since Monday night, Dave, we are almost at the end, we're almost at the show wrap. Excited to bring back, we've been talking about security, a lot about security. Excited to bring back a, an alumni to talk about that. But what's your final thoughts? >>Well, so just in, in, in the context of security, we've had just three in a row talking about cyber, which is like the most important topic. And I, and I love that we're having Palo Alto Networks on Palo Alto Networks is the gold standard in security. Talk to CISOs, they wanna work with them. And, and it was, it's interesting because I've been following them for a little bit now, watch them move to the cloud and a couple of little stumbling points. But I said at the time, they're gonna figure it out and, and come rocking back. And they have, and the company's just performing unbelievably well despite, you know, all the macro headwinds that we love to >>Talk about. So. Right. And we're gonna be unpacking all of that with one of our alumni. As I mentioned, Anker Shaw is with us, the SVP and GM of Palo Alto Networks. Anker, welcome back to the Cub. It's great to see you. It's been a while. >>It's good to be here after a couple years. Yeah, >>Yeah. I think three. >>Yeah, yeah, for sure. Yeah. Yeah. It's a bit of a blur after Covid. >>Everyone's saying that. Yeah. Are you surprised that there are still this many people on the show floor? Cuz I am. >>I am. Yeah. Look, I am not, this is my fourth, last year was probably one third or one fourth of this size. Yeah. But pre covid, this is what dream went looked like. And it's energizing, it's exciting. It's just good to be doing the good old things. So many people and yeah. Amazing technology and innovation. It's been incredible. >>Let's talk about innovation. I know you guys, Palo Alto Networks recently acquired cyber security. Talk to us a little bit about that. How is it gonna compliment Prisma? Give us all the scoop on that. >>Yeah, for sure. Look, some of the recent, the cybersecurity attacks that we have seen are related to supply chain, the colonial pipeline, many, many supply chain. And the reason for that is the modern software supply chain, not the physical supply chain, the one that AWS announced, but this is the software supply chain is really incredibly complicated, complicated developers that are building and shipping code faster than ever before. And the, the site acquisition at the center, the heart of that was securing the entire supply chain. White House came with a new initiative on supply chain security and SBO software bill of material. And we needed a technology, a company, and a set of people who can really deliver to that. And that's why we acquired that for supply chain security, otherwise known as cicd, security, c >>IDC security. Yeah. So how will that complement PRIs McCloud? >>Yeah, so look, if you look at our history lease over the last four years, we have been wanting to, our mission mission has been to build a single code to cloud platform. As you may know, there are over 3000 security vendors in the industry. And we said enough is enough. We need a platform player who can really deliver a unified cohesive platform solution for our customers because they're sick and tired of buying PI point product. So our mission has been to deliver that code to cloud platform supply chain security was a missing piece and we acquired them, it fits right really nicely into our portfolio of products and solution that customers have. And they'll have a single pin of glass with this. >>Yeah. So there's a lot going on. You've got, you've got an adversary that is incredibly capable. Yeah. These days and highly motivated and extremely sophisticated mentioned supply chain. It's caused a shift in, in CSO strategies, talking about the pandemic, of course we know work from home that changed things. You've mentioned public policy. Yeah. And, and so, and as well you have the cloud, cloud, you know, relatively new. I mean, it's not that new, but still. Yeah. But you've got the shared responsibility model and not, not only do you have the shared responsibility model, you have the shared responsibility across clouds and OnPrem. So yes, the cloud helps with security, but that the CISO has to worry about all these other things. The, the app dev team is being asked to shift left, you know, secure and they're not security pros. Yeah. And you know, kind audit is like the last line of defense. So I love this event, I love the cloud, but customers need help in making their lives simpler. Yeah. And the cloud in and of itself, because, you know, shared responsibility doesn't do that. Yeah. That's what Palo Alto and firms like yours come in. >>Absolutely. So look, Jim, this is a unable situation for a lot of the Cisco, simply because there are over 26 million developers, less than 3 million security professional. If you just look at all the announcement the AWS made, I bet you there were like probably over 2000 features. Yeah. I mean, they're shipping faster than ever before. Developers are moving really, really fast and just not enough security people to keep up with the velocity and the innovation. So you are right, while AWS will guarantee securing the infrastructure layer, but everything that is built on top of it, the new machine learning stuff, the new application, the new supply chain applications that are developed, that's the responsibility of the ciso. They stay up at night, they don't know what's going on because developers are bringing new services and new technology. And that's why, you know, we've always taken a platform approach where customers and the systems don't have to worry about it. >>What AWS new service they have, it's covered, it's secured. And that's why the adopters, McCloud and Palo Alto Networks, because regardless what developers bring, security is always there by their side. And so security teams need just a simple one click solution. They don't have to worry about it. They can sleep at night, keep the bad actors away. And, and that's, that's where Palo Alto Networks has been innovating in this area. AWS is one of our biggest partners and you know, we've integrated with, with a lot of their services. We launch about three integrations with their services. And we've been doing this historically for more and >>More. Are you still having conversations with the security folks? Or because security is a board level conversation, are your conversations going up a stack because this is a C-suite problem, this is a board level initiative? >>Absolutely. Look, you know, there was a time about four years ago, like the best we could do is director of security. Now it's just so CEO level conversation, board level conversation to your point, simply because I mean, if, if all your financial stuff is going to public cloud, all your healthcare data, all your supply chain data is going to public cloud, the board is asking very simple question, what are you doing to secure that? And to be honest, the question is simple. The answer's not because all the stuff that we talked about, too many applications, lots and lots of different services, different threat vectors and the bad actors, the bad guys are always a step ahead of the curve. And that's why this has become a board level conversation. They wanna make sure that things are secure from the get go before, you know, the enterprises go too deep into public cloud adoption. >>I mean there, there was shift topics a little bit. There was hope or kinda early this year that that cyber was somewhat insulated from the sort of macro press pressures. Nobody's safe. Even the cloud is sort of, you know, facing those, those headwinds people optimizing costs. But one thing when you talk to customers is, I always like to talk about that, that optiv graph. We've all seen it, right? And it's just this eye test of tools and it's a beautiful taxonomy, but there's just too many tools. So we're seeing a shift from point tools to platforms because obviously a platform play, and that's a way. So what are you seeing in the, in the field with customers trying to optimize their infrastructure costs with regard to consolidating to >>Platforms? Yeah. Look, you rightly pointed out one thing, the cybersecurity industry in general and Palo Alto networks, knock on wood, the stocks doing well. The macro headwinds hasn't impacted the security spend so far, right? Like time will tell, we'll, we'll see how things go. And one of the primary reason is that when you know the economy starts to slow down, the customers again want to invest in platforms. It's simple to deploy, simple to operationalize. They want a security partner of choice that knows that they, it's gonna be by them through the entire journey from code to cloud. And so that's why platform, especially times like these are more important than they've ever been before. You know, customers are investing in the, the, the product I lead at Palo Alto network called Prisma Cloud. It's in the cloud network application protection platform seen app space where once again, customers that investing in platform from quote to cloud and avoiding all the point products for sure. >>Yeah. Yeah. And you've seen it in, in Palo Alto's performance. I mean, not every cyber firm has is, is, >>You know, I know. Ouch. CrowdStrike Yeah. >>Was not. Well you saw that. I mean, and it was, and and you know, the large customers were continuing to spend, it was the small and mid-size businesses Yeah. That were, were were a little bit soft. Yeah. You know, it's a really, it's really, I mean, you see Okta now, you know, after they had some troubles announcing that, you know, their, their, their visibility's a little bit better. So it's, it's very hard to predict right now. And of course if TOMA Brava is buying you, then your stock price has been up and steady. That's, >>Yeah. Look, I think the key is to have a diversified portfolio of products. Four years ago before our CEO cash took over the reins of the company, we were a single product X firewall company. Right. And over time we have added XDR with the first one to introduce that recently launched x Im, you know, to, to make sure we build an NextGen team, cloud security is a completely net new investment, zero trust with access as workers started working remotely and they needed to make sure enterprises needed to make sure that they're accessing the applications securely. So we've added a lot of portfolio products over time. So you have to remain incredibly diversified, stay strong, because there will be stuff like remote work that slowed down. But if you've got other portfolio product like cloud security, while those secular tailwinds continue to grow, I mean, look how fast AWS is growing. 35, 40%, like $80 billion run rate. Crazy at that, that scale. So luckily we've got the portfolio of products to ensure that regardless of what the customer's journey is, macro headwinds are, we've got portfolio of solutions to help our customers. >>Talk a little bit about the AWS partnership. You talked about the run rate and I was reading a few days ago. You're right. It's an 82 billion arr, massive run rate. It's crazy. Well, what are, what is a Palo Alto Networks doing with aws and what's the value in it to help your customers on a secure digital transformation journey? >>Well, absolutely. We have been doing business with aws. We've been one of their security partners of choice for many years now. We have a presence in the marketplace where customers can through one click deploy the, the several Palo Alto Networks security solutions. So that's available. Like I said, we had launch partner to many, many new products and innovation that AWS comes up with. But always the day one partner, Adam was talking about some of those announcements and his keynote security data lake was one of those. And they were like a bunch of others related to compute and others. So we have been a partner for a long time, and look, AWS is an incredibly customer obsessed company. They've got their own security products. But if the customer says like, Hey, like I'd like to pick this from yours, but there's three other things from Palo Alto Networks or S MacCloud or whatever else that may be, they're open to it. And that's the great thing about AWS where it doesn't have to be wall garden open ecosystem, let the customer pick the best. >>And, and that's, I mean, there's, there's examples where AWS is directly competitive. I mean, my favorite example is Redshift and Snowflake. I mean those are directly competitive products, but, but Snowflake is an unbelievably great relationship with aws. They do cyber's, I think different, I mean, yeah, you got guard duty and you got some other stuff there. But generally speaking, the, correct me if I'm wrong, the e the ecosystem has more room to play on AWS than it may on some other clouds. >>A hundred percent. Yeah. Once again, you know, guard duty for examples, we've got a lot of customers who use guard duty and Prisma Cloud and other Palo Alto Networks products. And we also ingest the data from guard duty. So if customers want a single pane of glass, they can use the best of AWS in terms of guard duty threat detection, but leverage other technology suite from, you know, a platform provider like Palo Alto Networks. So you know, that that, you know, look, world is a complicated place. Some like blue, some like red, whatever that may be. But we believe in giving customers that choice, just like AWS customers want that. Not a >>Problem. And at least today they're not like directly, you know, in your space. Yeah. You know, and even if they were, you've got such a much mature stack. Absolutely. And my, my frankly Microsoft's different, right? I mean, you see, I mean even the analysts were saying that some of the CrowdStrike's troubles for, cuz Microsoft's got the good enough, right? So >>Yeah. Endpoint security. Yeah. And >>Yeah, for sure. So >>Do you have a favorite example of a customer where Palo Alto Networks has really helped them come in and, and enable that secure business transformation? Anything come to mind that you think really shines a light on Palo Alto Networks and what it's able to do? >>Yeah, look, we have customers across, and I'm gonna speak to public cloud in general, right? Like Palo Alto has over 60,000 customers. So we've been helping with that business transformation for years now. But because it's reinvented aws, the Prisma cloud product has been helping customers across different industry verticals. Some of the largest credit card processing companies, they can process transactions because we are running security on top of the workloads, the biggest financial services, biggest healthcare customers. They're able to put the patient health records in public cloud because Palo Alto Networks is helping them get there. So we are helping accelerated that digital journey. We've been an enabler. Security is often perceived as a blocker, but we have always treated our role as enabler. How can we get developers and enterprises to move as fast as possible? And like, my favorite thing is that, you know, moving fast and going digital is not a monopoly of just a tech company. Every company is gonna be a tech company Oh absolutely. To public cloud. Yes. And we want to help them get there. Yeah. >>So the other thing too, I mean, I'll just give you some data. I love data. I have a, ETR is our survey partner and I'm looking at Data 395. They do a survey every quarter, 1,250 respondents on this survey. 395 were Palo Alto customers, fortune 500 s and P 500, you know, big global 2000 companies as well. Some small companies. Single digit churn. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. Very, very low replacement >>Rates. Absolutely. >>And still high single digit new adoption. Yeah. Right. So you've got that tailwind going for you. Yeah, >>Right. It's, it's sticky because especially our, our main business firewall, once you deploy the firewall, we are inspecting all the network traffic. It's just so hard to rip and replace. Customers are getting value every second, every minute because we are thwarting attacks from public cloud. And look, we, we, we provide solutions not just product, we just don't leave the product and ask the customers to deploy it. We help them with deployment consumption of the product. And we've been really fortunate with that kind of gross dollar and netten rate for our customers. >>Now, before we wrap, I gotta tease, the cube is gonna be at Palo Alto Ignite. Yeah. In two weeks back here. I think we're at D mgm, right? We >>Were at D MGM December 13th and >>14th. So give us a little, show us a little leg if you would. What could we expect? >>Hey, look, I mean, a lot of exciting new things coming. Obviously I can't talk about it right now. The PR Inc is still not dry yet. But lots of, lots of new innovation across our three main businesses. Network security, public cloud, security, as well as XDR X. Im so stay tuned. You know, you'll, you'll see a lot of new exciting things coming up. >>Looking forward to it. >>We are looking forward to it. Last question on curf. You, if you had a billboard to place in New York Times Square. Yeah. You're gonna take over the the the Times Square Nasdaq. What does the billboard say about why organizations should be working with Palo Alto Networks? Yeah. To really embed security into their dna. Yeah. >>You know when Jim said Palo Alto Networks is the gold standard for security, I thought it was gonna steal it. I think it's pretty good gold standard for security. But I'm gonna go with our mission cyber security partner's choice. We want to be known as that and that's who we are. >>Beautifully said. Walker, thank you so much for joining David in the program. We really appreciate your insights, your time. We look forward to seeing you in a couple weeks back here in Vegas. >>Absolutely. Can't have enough of Vegas. Thank you. Lisa. >>Can't have in Vegas, >>I dunno about that. By this time of the year, I think we can have had enough of Vegas, but we're gonna be able to see you on the cubes coverage, which you could catch up. Palo Alto Networks show Ignite December, I believe 13th and 14th on the cube.net. We want to thank Anker Shaw for joining us. For Dave Ante, this is Lisa Martin. You're watching the Cube, the leader in live enterprise and emerging tech coverage.

>>Locke from Las Vegas. It's the cube covering AWS reinvent 2019 brought to you by Amazon web services and along with its ecosystem partners. >>Well, welcome back to the cube live here in Las Vegas for AWS reinvent 2019 it's the cubes seventh year, eighth year of reinvent. We've been there almost from the beginning. I'm John ferry with Dave Volante extracting the signal from the noise. The two great guests here chew senior leaders, VMware, auntie that were Sanjay Poonan, COO of VMware cube alumni, Mike Clayville, vice president of worldwide commercial sales and business development for AWS guys. You're the senior leaders out on the field making things happen. I got to say the AWS VMware relationship, which we covered a couple of years ago when Gelsinger and Jassy were doing the little love Fest, they're in San Francisco. A lot of people were skeptical. This show here, we're hearing things like, that's my Superbowl moment. Things are working great. Cloud is scaling, so congratulations and welcome to the cube. Good to see you. Thank you. Yeah. All right, so let's get to the relationship. >>Talk about you guys' relationship and how it's morphed into such a success. We're hearing great feedback. The numbers on the research at day's been digging into shows. Customer spend is up. Is that the wave of cloud? Is that the integration? Sanjay, what's going on? Give us, gives you up to, Oh, I think we're delighted. You know Mike obviously and I have been friends for years. He's had some connections with VMware in his past that certainly helped in setting up this partnerships. So we're grateful to Mike and Andy and the team for that and it's, you know, two and a half to three years now since we announced it. Tremendous amount of customer interest. Listen, you know we said at the beginning of this, when you take sort of the King of the public cloud and the King, the private cloud together and don't force customers to say these have to be separate doors, you're going to do them both together. >>Customers liked that message and what we've been really doing over the course of the last 1218 months is perfecting use cases for this platform. I think to us, the key word is migrations. Cloud migrations. When people are moving their workloads off an app off VMware vSphere or cloud foundation, we want this to be the best place for it to land. We are McCloud in AWS for migration opportunity and anything short of that refactoring app would we, you know, not something that would be a good use of people's time and money because they should be then modernizing with all the wonderful services that Amazon's built, one they've migrated. So we've really perfected our message in the course of the last six, 12 months to two M's, migrate and modernize, migrate and modernize. So we could migrate you into this Avenue and then modernize with a set of container and other services. So that messes working. We put on stage at VMworld and there are many of them here, two big Amazon customers, VMware cloud, Amazon, Freddie Mac and IHS market. And they were telling our tens of thousands customers at those shows and similarly many of them here, that that's the best option to be able to do things. >>Yeah, it's great. It's great by the way, because it's a frictionless migration, right? So you've got a platform that same code base working on pram, same cloud based and cloud creating a seamless integration between the two platforms. We're finding customers very in enthralled by that. I say they say they love that because it's less disruptive for them. Yeah. But at the same time they say, but eventually I want to change my operating model to really drive profits to my bottom line. So could you talk a little bit about what that journey looks like? And I'm really interested in longer term Sanjay, how you play in that. I look Mike, sorry. So the first thing I'd say that one of the real reasons I love it is because they've got a big investment today and that investment is in skills. That investment is in operational processes. That investment is in licensing and all of that comes along with them on their journey. Whether it's a migration journey or a migration to modernize journey, it's working. So when you're talking about the bottom line, like you are, this is a great play for that bottom line. >>Yeah, I know. And I'd say, listen, from our perspective, we want to take a Freddie Mac. When they spoke at VMworld, they have I think 800 applications, 50 of whom are SAS and the other 750 are custom built, deep Lee virtualized and they're going to move all of them over the course of the next 12 months. I fell off my chair when I, when I heard how fast they planned to do it. IHS market has very a variety of very spread accounts and Amazon. Now we're going to help them move a lot of their workloads there. Once they're there, we want them to then use the tools that Amazon's bill. I'll give you two examples, maybe some of their backup tools into S3 CloudWatch some of their analytical monitoring types of tools. So there's going to be, and then of course AI database services and the best place once you've moved it there is to make sure that that migrated stack is stable. >>You have the best of the VMware tools, V center, V motion, all you know and the best of the Amazon tools. So when people start to see this, I think the myth of Sarah's saying refactor and replatform that application, which is in essence like taking a home. Okay. And having to destroy the home and completely rebuild it. Right? And that's just a meal, a waste of money and time when you could migrate it and then modernize it. So we just need to get that story well understood. Get our, you know, I, I mean Amazon probably has a few million customers. We have a half a million customers. If all of those customers can hear the story and beginning their journey with us, I think we will tip this in a way. Starting >>to tip, to get the, back to the point of your question as well. Look, our two companies have been engineering these solutions together deeply. So this just isn't a paper arbiters. Yeah. This is an engineering partnership that started years ago and what that means is as customers migrate to a beam ware on AWS, now they have access to over 175 AWS services, can it, right. Significant native access to a broad range of services that they can continue to innovate, identify new business models and it all seamlessly integrates back into a single platform. >>Yeah. One of the things I always said when I talked to Andy and Amazon folks is that the competitive advantage of the businesses scale and also the new announcements that come in. So one of the things we heard yesterday from a customer, uh, one of your joint customers was, you know, I asked him about outpost, which you guys now are going to ship in 2020, which was announced you already got native outpost, general availability. He goes, look it, we'd love VMware. We could probably look at VMware and kind of poke at things, maybe do things differently. But frankly I don't want to have to rearchitect my stack because I want the data science stuff from studio a Sage maker studio because the demand for the business results is coming in from the new capabilities. So this seems to be the trend where the migration is just lift and shifts, keep the operational flow going, foundation and the business value over the top is whatever you guys can bring in from an NSX and then the apps. Is this something that you're hearing more of? Because this points to all of us, the discussion around the platform is irrelevant because the business value is coming in from the data. Yeah. What, how do you guys react to that? Is that something that you're hearing? >>Well, the first thing I would say is the, you know, the pundents will tell you that by 2020 90% of customers will be in a hybrid model. So you know, the migration is, you talk about is in play and, and arguably 2020 will be the year of the most migrations in history if those pendants are correct. Right. And so that gets a lot of customers in the mode of being able to leverage a BMC and then be able to take advantage of all the, you know, the extensive amount of data services we have available. But if you ask me, where do you know, what are the, what are the big reasons driving the migration? It's traditional economics, right? It's, I'm, I don't need to be a capital expense heavy organization anymore. Why do I have to build data centers? Why do I have to extend data centers? Why am I building, why am I buying air conditioning that's not differentiating my business? Right? All of those things are creating drivers for this migration. Now as you begin the migration, that's when you begin to see, wow, imagine the simplicity of the same code base, same operational processes. I don't have to retrain a bunch of people just moving it right onto the cloud and now let me really dig in to the new services available from AWS. Look for those new business. >>I suppose having that focus of differentiation and VMware and saying, let's keep it and expand it to the edge and do things like that. And yeah, absolutely. I mean, listen, I think they had Cerner yesterday on stage and I think it was interesting to hear the CEO, they're talking about three verbs, migrated, modernize, and innovate. I mean that's the thing thing. So I think when you, when you start to see that becoming a very active dialogue, not just from CEOs but from CEOs and boards that are saying, listen, you know, part of the reason we want to move to the cloud is an increase our bruiser agility. It's not just a cost reduction. Yeah. I mean I don't need to have 80 data centers have, I could have half a zero a one or two so that I get, but beyond cost, if we can kind of get agility going faster. >>And for many of these folks, I think when I sit down in their customer advisory councils, when I, when we are advising them, they're all trying to serve their customers better, get data to become sort of the oil of their ability to make decisions better and AI and analytics sort of help in that area. And then of course, getting more efficient in lowering costs and risks. And I think when you're doing it, the scale that both of us have experienced doing, we understand data centers really well. We've software defined them for 20 years. These guys understand cloud probably better than anybody else. When we bring that sort of scale together and as Mike pointed out, a deeply engineered solution, we have a, we have a significant R and D investment in this and we're doing that jointly with them. When I often sit down in our joint QPRs, I joke about it with Mike and Andy and others, I sometimes forget, is that a VMware person speaking or an Amazon person because there's finishing each other's sentences. So there's a lot of that joint trust they've built and we just now have to keep showing that this is a solution that's innovating every three months because you're running on monthly and quarterly cycles and get large customers. I mean to us now, it's less so about the noise of getting everybody on stage. It's much more of a showing customer attraction. >>So I wonder if we could talk about one of the other big problems in the industry. Mikey talked about deep engineering and you guys are, you know, you're never done right, but you've solved that problem or solving that problem of making it easy for customers, VM-ware customers to run in the cloud. There's another big problem it could be concerned about customers is security and there seems to be somewhat of a dissonance. And I wonder if you could share with us maybe some of the thinking around this. So Steven Schmidt for instance, who is Amazon CSO says, Hey, the state of security in the cloud is, is great. And it is, it's, you know, you don't have a lot of technical debt coming in to the game. Pat Gelsinger is saying, Hey, you know, security, the state of security in my world is broken. So what's the conversation with you guys in terms of addressing that big concern on the minds of CEOs? And >>yeah, I'll start and they might feel free to add them. Thomas, I mean we've talked to Steve, we're like Steve, he's a very, he's a, he's an innovator and a thought leader in security. We're coming at it from a place that's complimentary to some of the point of views of, of Amazon. Um, and I shared this at our last VM world discussion. When we look at the, the, the control points of security where traditional security spent network, endpoint, identity, cloud and analytics, those are five, four control points where a lot of security is spent inside the $50 billion security market. We picked two that we're going to do really well. The network and endpoint NSX has been doing really well there. Now granted a bunch of that is on prem. It's replacing or complimenting Cisco, Palo Alto, checkpoint fire, a flash for a railroad bed, F five NetScaler spent. >>And now that business 13,000 customers in has become a 40, 50% of its security use cases. The network we just acquired, carbon black aide runs on the Amazon platform. It runs, uh, a next gen endpoint security. That's, you know, an evolution from the old world of Symantec, McAfee, you know, and there were only two vendors doing this at scale carbon black and CrowdStrike, we built, we built, we bought the better one. So when you put those together and collect a significant amount of telemetry from that, we think we could do something highly differentiated and security. So VMware, his goal and to the extent that Amazon or others are doing things in security that compliment our view of it, we'll build on it, right? Whether it's identity and access tools, whether it's load balancers, whether it's security, event management capabilities. >>Well we're in, we're integrating those two into the security in the cloud, which makes it seamless security, which is critical. >>Goal would be, listen, when we go and when we talked about this is what we're doing, security, we go to Mike and Andy and Steve and said, listen, this is our ambitions and security. We don't view Amazon as a competitor. And that's why he's very much complimented. They'll will be on the fringes. They have a load balancer. We now have a cloud. But that's okay. But that's the bigger part. If they were going off for endpoint security, as we be competitive there, if they were going up in network secure, but they're not. So I think when we share our intents, which we do very openly, we have open kimono sessions. He, this is where we are, this is where we're going. That's what we, and we go deep in that >>trust luck, but this is a historic partnership. This is not a partnership that I've seen anywhere in the industry in my 35 years. This is something that's at the next level and I think you'll look back, history will look back at this partnership and and recognize that its impact on cloud is going to be substantial. >>You hope you guys deserve a lot of credit and again, the critics were critical of the announcement. We were obviously favor, we saw the vision, but I think what surprised me most is that the spend numbers reflect is you guys clarified your cloud play with this move. The customers saluted it 100% they were on board and the numbers are showing it, but as Andy and you guys go to the next level, I got to get your thoughts on this trend of transformation. We have two means. We started in the cube this week. One was if you take the T out of cloud native, it's cloud naive. And the other one is what I said in my post about being reborn in the cloud. So you've got born in the cloud, startups and growth and enterprises were becoming reborn, okay? In the cloud, which means they're transforming. >>So as that trillions of dollars that are coming into the migration, you look at the numbers, there's only 20% of it spend in cloud. Roughly give or take. You're talking about trillions of dollars of new money. You guys are the commercial guys. Hey look, it's still day one for the cloud. It's still day one. I agree. You have a lot of people who might not make the migration, might die of starvation. Okay? As they move to the new model, you guys are out there have to take and you're going to go get that cash. What are you guys seeing? Cause this is a big trillions and trillions of dollars are on the table. You started Mike off. Well look. So, >>you know, uh, Sanjay talked about you see these customers and how enthusiastic they are about the opportunity here, right? And, and Freddie Mac's a great example of 100 million lines of code, and I've got to get out of three data centers in 24 months. Bam, they're out in 10, 10 months, 10 months, right? Um, 100 million lines of code over hundreds of, of applications done in 10 months. Now imagine the rest that the company can do now that they got that behind him, right? And that's what we're seeing is this partnership enables our customers to get a bunch done very economically, much faster, and now they can get onto the other things that they need to do. >>Yeah. And I'd build on that. Listen, you know, we track about a trillion dollars of it spend. And if you add up all of the cloud spend today, it's probably a, I mean, Amazon and Salesforce are probably the biggest in infrastructure and apps. It's probably 150 billion in total cloud spend, maybe 200 billion. So that's 15 to 20% of the total it spend, which is massive, but it's still as, as my points, that's early innings is that 20% it's probably going to become 50% at some point soon, right? If you look at the pace at which the cloud companies are growing, so the key question is, is going to go as 150 billion, the 1 trillion total number is going to grow, but probably a little bit faster and GDP most every 5% max, who's going to go grab that 150 Boone as it goes from 150 billion to 500 billion and the on premise spend slows down. >>Right? Um, I think that, you know, I think Amazon is very well positioned and from our perspective at VMware, we have a, you know, 10 $11 billion business. We're trying to tilt this increasingly more cloud. We announced our earnings call, 13% of it now is hybrid cloud and SAS, that 13% should become 2025 50. They are a pure cloud company. 100% of their businesses is cloud. We're in that transition. But why are we in that transition? Because we see that 150 billion of it spend likely becoming 500 billion. And if we don't get it somebody else's well hybrids, are we a tailwind for you guys? Because outpost is actually a statement that says hybrid at the edge. Now the data centers an edge, you've got edge. What is an edge? So cloud operations is now the standard and we, I mean, we actually coined the term hybrid six years ago and everyone could five, six years ago and everyone really laughed at us and now I think it's being validated. So it's, it's very gratifying now that Amazon has a similar vision to hybrid as us. Uh, we believe both the VMware cloud on Amazon outpost and BMR cloud running on outpost, we're very committed to that joint vision. >>Yeah. You're talking about the spending data and you know, VMware yet another revenue hit. I was pretty consistent in that and that standpoint. But if you look at the spending data, virtually every sort of traditional company with very few exceptions is you're seeing a share shift to the cloud. VMware is an exception. It didn't use to be that way a couple of years ago, but you're embracing the cloud really changed and became, you may cloud a tailwind right now to headwind. >>I think this partnership helped in that area and you put it right, right. Everything in life is either an opportunity or a threat. I think, and I've talked about it in your show before, cloud and containers were a significant threat. When I joined Amazon, sorry, when I was partners with Amazon, I joined VMware six years ago. I asked Pat and I said, listen, I think the threats to VMR, Amazon and Docker in 2013 now Docker is a whole different story. Kubernetes took their head out. Uh, but to our credit we joined credit, we partnered here and I think from our perspective, see, we at VMware aren't able to do a complete pivot like Adobe did to say burn the boats on, on premise and completely shift everything. SAS. Why? Because customers still want NSX on prem. Customers still want our HCI product on prem. People are still buying vSphere on prem. >>So we've got this more delicate balance of starting to shift and on-prem business. The aircraft carrier, you know at the time, 5,000,000,005, six years ago now, 11 billion to something that's a blend of on prem and cloud. While the cloud part grows a lot faster, that 13% of revenue we announced our earnings call is growing 40% yeah. So we can keep that growing foster and foster while the on-prem business is not decaying, it's still growing but not growing at the same pace, plus changing its end, make that transition a few years from now to being a lot more of a cloud company. >>The other thing you're seeing in the spending data, I wonder if you could comment is, you know, digital initiatives really started in earnest, let's say 2016 and people were doing a lot of experimentation. They were throwing everything for the new stuff against the wall. And what we're seeing now is they're narrowing the new and they were keeping the legacy stuff around because they were sort of running in parallel to hedge their bets. What we're seeing now is less experimentation in the new, and they're starting to unplug some of the older stuff. What they're not unplugging is cloud and they're hanging on to VMware and we're seeing, you know, spending levels revert to pre 2018 levels. I wonder what you guys are seeing at the macro. >>Well, the first thing I would say is I see experimentation continuing to accelerate, right? All of the new functionality that we bring out every day. Everybody's excuse, you're the sandbox for us. It's very invigorating because we love people to experiment and, uh, and we, you know, a lot of those experiments turned into amazing new startups as an example. And, or a bunch of those experiments turned into major new project projects in our, in our big, uh, enterprises. So we're continuing to see a real push towards experimentation and driving agility into the business. I don't know. Yeah, >>no, I, well, Mike, I'd agree. I mean, listen, we in some senses, uh, we have a very good strong, you know, on-premise business and when we see a really innovative company that's in the order of 33 35%, that's already 35 three 35 billion growing in the forties 30 to 40% I mean that's incredible. When we see companies like Salesforce and Adobe that are giant SAS companies approaching, you know, 10 1115 20 billion growing 2020 5% I think that infrastructure is a service and SAS business for us are trailblazers of where this cloud is headed now, these, the biggest companies in infrastructure and in SAS and we follow that. Now we have to then navigate to say, listen, the growth rates and the spending is going to be reflected by cloud spend that's heavily spending on there. And the way in which the on premise world is what spending, we have a bunch of hardware companies, we work very closely. >>We're watching how that spending is, is playing OD, whether it's Cisco, whether it's HP, whether it's Lenovo, Dell and others. And then of course we've got VM. We're sitting right in between and I think what we're trying to manage as you got a whole world of on-prem driven primarily by hardware companies. You've got a bunch of these cloud new companies, Amazon, Salesforce, Adobe, and we have a right in the middle saying, okay, listen, we want to be dragged by both while many of our customers still want some on prem. It's a delicate balance, but there's no, um, I mean we are very clear within VMware. We want to be led by a cloud first policy wherever we can. I'll give you an example. Workspace one, manage these devices. We want a company five years ago named AirWatch, why did we buy them versus somebody else? >>It was cloud. It was cloud-first that business now and use a computing has stilted itself to be primarily cloud-based, very subscription-based. It was on premise VDI at the time Mike was at the company six, seven years ago. It's become now completely cloud based on the back of a workspace one, you know, kind of thing. So that's how we're thinking about it. The new acquisitions we've done, whether it's carbon black, whether it's Velo club, it's CloudHealth. They're all cloud-based. Well, you guys made a good bet on cloud operations. That's the real shift. The cloud operation model is right in your wheelhouse. You guys have operators, VMware, you guys have cloud operations everywhere now edge with outpost. Congratulations. I want to say, Sanjay, it's been a great journey with you. You've been with the cube all 10 years. All seven years. We've been actually the 10 year anniversary. >>We've been documenting the history. Wow. The historic moments like you guys together writing AWS, really appreciate it. and of course that was good to see more action coming. Cloud 2.0 next gen. Cloud competition controversies. I mean what? You can't ask for a better movie here. John. Dave, I'm going to, we're going to bring mugs next time. Okay. We're going to have mugs.. I'm John for Dave a lot. They saw Jay Poon and Mike Clayville, the leaders, senior leaders of AWS and VMware out with their customers here on the queue. This is our AWS Intel set in the middle of the floor here at reinvent 2019 our seventh year. Thanks for watching more coverage day two of the queue. We'll be right back.

live from san francisco extracting the signal from the noise it's the cute covering oracle openworld 2015 brought to you by oracle now your host John furrier okay welcome back everyone we are here live in San Francisco on Howard Street for oracle openworld special presentation of the cube so looking ankles flagship program we go out to the events and extract the system noise i'm john furrier founder of SiliconANGLE join my next to gas prakash ramamurthy senior vice president systems and cloud management basically management cloud at oracle and mary johnson Turner research vice president enterprise systems management IDC welcome to the cube thank you so I think take my glasses off to read read the intro there but I want to just get your take on it because we just had to admit on Lavery talk about the plowed and one question I didn't get to ask him was a success mark hurry was talk about the pipeline of customers already in motion on the cloud so I wanted to ask him which is great timing for you guys is how do they integrate it which he talked about but then how do they manage if this is a big issue and he you know ease of use is something that he was generally throwing around there so what is the status of the management cloud because that will be a differentiator like security and to end as a differentiator management certainly will be to me not just table stakes it's really differentiated absolutely i think we're here because we're launching it today actually the management cloud and the interesting thing is this which is today if you look at it whether it's on our cloud or on-premise the rate of innovation is very very robust right i mean you have a mobile phone you're seeing your apps getting refresh twice a week or or even faster than that so what it means is you need the next generation monitoring solution that can monitor all of that so our goal with oracle management flower is to help you manage and monitor your solutions independent of where they are deployed if you deploy it on oracle cloud you little come bake with it to be able to monitor it right from the get-go or if you still have it on premise we will allow you to monitor it and break down those data I low so it is very effective so like you said is very very critical that people look at what their challenges are today in terms of proactive monitoring and troubleshooting to get to the next generation solutions we are providing theory I want to ask you a question on the trends but before that I want to just say that one of things i love about doing the oracle shells are six year the cube here is that for an old-timer like me seen the client-server live the client-server Revolution which is now kind of almost a point in time now it's almost it's over now we're into the cloud cloud modern error it's interesting to see because the same same things keep coming up again it's like the platform's the tool is so I got to ask you the question on what is the key trends that are driving this new application space because if you look at the client-server one of the big things that really was huge was the application market mean that would grant it was siloed up by you know by vendors but now with open source this is a huge application boom right now that's gonna impact IT operations sure yeah I think that if you look at it there's been like you said a couple of generations of technology we had mainframes things changed really slow right then we had client server which was to give business units and developers more control and things started to speed up and change a little more quickly but now in our current and cloud native cloud based development real-time microservice open source-based kind of world the rating pays the change is almost constant you're seeing so many organizations that are moving to continuous delivery modes much of it hosted on public cloud or hybrid private public cloud and they're changing features and functions every day and that creates huge management challenges in terms of just trying to understand is the end-to-end application performing effectively are the end-users getting what they need are the business decision-makers really understanding the impact of those outages or upgrades and it's so it's very complex and then I think it's raising the set of requirements for a particular application performance monitoring and IT operations and log analytics I was Oracle addressing these trends because one of the things that people like tonight I'd like to put things into two camps rip and replace okay or evolutionary development and we're clearly on the McCloud evolutionary because Oracle has it's not gonna be it's not gonna go away right so you can say Oracle native is the cloud strategy to all the Oracle customers but yet now with open source there's net new applications that do you got cha vows to 20 years anniversary so there's new stuff going on IOT is a huge application market right now now I can run an IOT thing in the cloud somewhere else or maybe on Amazon or somewhere else but the other day I have run through my operational assistance assistance of engagements this is a record which is Oracle right so is it an Oracle native cloud and the cloud data mean it how do you see oracle addressing that dynamic are they well positioned well i think oracle has a pretty broad portfolio you know they've had again from a management perspective they had Oracle Enterprise Manager on Prem for many many years i think that the new offerings that are being announced today really are interesting that they extend Oracles of monitoring and analytics to a whole range of cloud-based solutions many of which may not necessarily have been born on the Oracle platforms so I think it's a good recognition of the need for heterogeneity and the need to recognize that it is going to be a very hybrid world for many many years so I think that those are all real you know positive factors and then the new releases and it was talking about the integrated pass perform as a service Enchantix connect those environments but on the management side what are you guys delivering because that's going to be the challenge Prakash to talk about the specific things that you guys are announcing and delivering the customers today so specifically we are delivering three services first one is around application performance monitoring that allows our customers to stay ahead of their customers and their problems and give them the best user experience and monitor that and troubleshoot that and then the second service is around managing your logs and extracting IT operational data and business data out of it today if you look at it the most common thing people do with the log is to archive them and put it away because they don't want that to interrupt their production systems but that has a ton of good information so we have that second service eight exhaust becomes gold exactly so today what happens is they just get put away they get archived and that has real nuggets of business information and IT information being able to collect all of that and use it for your rapid troubleshooting as well so that's the second service the set third one is around IT analytics I call those first two services kind of like the Fitbit for your applications you're constantly getting vitals out of it and white throw that away if you don't have an issue still use it to run some interesting capacity friends and forecasting and all of that so use your real data to forecast your IT health as opposed to using a spreadsheet with some random data that you collected in a point in time so that's what we are announcing three services application performance monitoring log analytics and long term trending and forecasting with IT analytic Isis plunks been doing some log files how they were born people's blunt their data exactly they are trying to kind of get into that how do you guys compared to things like splunk and other tools I know tableau is a new relationship that was announced for the data visualization yeah Larry kind of talked about that yesterday talk about that how people are using that data exhaust give me some examples so the most fundamental difference in what we are doing is this which is we do not differentiate the sources of data and the classes of data when we bring it to the cloud so it could be metric data but with that you can collect based on your monitoring your health of your applications which splunk doesn't do for example and then log data but collect all of that and correlate it together so that in essence what we want to do is this which is the enterprise's today don't have a really a data problem they'd have an insight problem which is they want to be able to just see the right amount of data when they have a problem not all the data when they have a problem depends how you look at the data problem they'll have a Jerry problems you define that as they get all this data so you're plenty of data that's the problem there's no dearth of data problem yeah so that's what I'm i know i know i just kind of making this fun was good comment because i like that because that's that is really not an issue the data is coming yeah and that's you know Brandon whole know the problem you guys have scale now with that but the I don't Linux is a big thing I wanna talk about that because it can be problematic I'm a talk to some customers all the time and they say if someone comes in here and sells me another dashboard I'm gonna shoot myself exactly so it's like because and I said what do you mean by that he goes well there's so many alarms going off I don't know what to pay attention to that's where we start to see machine learning from these tools can you share any color what your great wine Larry I'm it's exactly right which is one of the underpinnings for us is to be able to automatically generate baseline and detect anomalies the last thing I mean our product support our own public cloud and I hear from the guys who run the cloud saying don't just give me another alert tell me what I need to do with an alert because I need to be able to disposition the alert so what we want to do is to understand the normal behavior of your application and only alerts you when there's an anomaly okay so that's part of our machine learning and prioritisation learning some learning algorithms in volved understand some pattern recognition that's right things and only tell you what the outlier is and when and and ask determine what the outlier is that suppose you setting thresholds for us to know it because sometimes things change if you are an e-commerce application or the day before Thanksgiving would have a different pattern than the third week of January right me just that the way the world works so what I want to talk to you about Larry made a comment yes in the key no I just like to take a dig at work day but you know in the way he likes work day because you know it's competition and also highlights from the features that Oracle has but what work days actually losing some share to service now a company in here in Silicon Valley that is an itsm IT service management company and they have been very successful their developer program which actually is starting to nibble away at work shares market share because they're building these developers are building these really focused age are apps that is not flat point it's a tool I know like an offense report for example and works really really well but work day has a plethora of features and they don't always have the best in class features uh-huh so that brings up the whole developer angle what do you and you guys have a story there for developers api's how do you talk to the absolutely share absolutely we have a rest api that the developers can use to collect the data from there into their own dashboards if they want to and also for example you can automatically deploy our agents when you're using our Java cloud service so that monitoring gets baked into it so we have api's for both inputting data and torque loud and extracting data back from the cloud will have api's for you to take the events that we generate into your own event dashboard that you have I'm a developer have a team like I could do some stuff filled my own kind of visualization UI and just have JSON endpoints come right into the absolution absolutely maybe I know she smirked when I said service now you will share some insight it's a this dynamic because this is kind of what's happening on the cloud these tools are popping up yeah well yeah and again I think what we're talking about today is to be able to monitor and analyze and optimize a lot of those different tools and deliver them via cloud platform and I think that we are finding that DevOps organizations are very interested in cloud-based solutions that help them do this better cheaper or faster so I think that you know I think it's an opportunity service now has currently been a pioneer in the delivery of system management as a cloud based model and I think it's interesting that Oracle is actually choosing to enter that market in in a different place yeah I mean actually I just a strength and you got the systems of record a on the right and and really talk from your really you know to Prakash this point really focusing on data because managing effectively managing the performance and operation of applications and complex environments it's all it is a huge data problem and you've got data coming from so many sources so many formats and being able to take that in rapidly to transform it normalize it and make it digestible for humans it's something that is really important in these complex environments and yes I think it's going to be interesting to see I think it's a great try or agree with you I think it's a great strategy by focusing on the data you have a lot of range and I wrote a blog post in 2007 now I'm going way back date is a new developer kit and now that's actually happening you look at data people are playing with the data like a developer place with function calls if you will so we're seeing now is a data rich environment hence the not not a problem of having enough data laying around the problem is how do you use the data you're getting all the products yeah inside is a huge problem and that's only an accelerated by faster performance machines in easy-to-use environment like I'd better analytics because you you want if the user knows what the problem is that they're looking for there are a lot of tools that will help you find it yeah but if you do not know what the problem is and to guide them towards the problem is is where where there's real opportunity and there's a real pain point in these enterprises especially now that you and I don't tolerate a downtime so you never cut anybody slack saying oh the website is slow but they've been innovating I'm gonna give them some slack nobody does that yeah yeah so and because now everything is measurable now for the first time in the history of business everything is measurable that's right and that's like just mind-blowing to me but i think is a huge app i only get your thoughts on the application market because I just see a massive tsunami coming of third-party developers and I'm not sure Oracle can handle that I didn't that's my personal opinion counter that I mean I people want to know can Oracle handle an ecosystem of third-party developers absolutely we have shown that before with with Java and I think you see every one of four services having open api's we are coating third-party developers we will be continuing to support them and I think we'll be able to handle it and we need to do that as a part of this ecosystem yeah I mean it's a platform yeah so you have to enable absolutely and that's the open message exactly all right so gosh what's your advice for the people at oracle openworld here and the people watching let's start with the people here on site if they catch this video when are we putting up some snippets before you even get off the set here so one what session should they attend what's where should I get more information what sessions and breakouts and then presentations they goes I have a keynote tomorrow at 11am that I would love for them to attend and outside of that there are some hands-on labs here that they should go look at the products and people who are remote they should go to cloud.oracle.com / management where we have all the services listed and take a look at it and we are really really going to be putting out a very differentiated solution than what is available in the marketplace and I would love for them to check it out and give us feedback for the folks watching online and customers in general when they squint through all the activities a lot of bombs dropping here at Oracle I mean a lot of announcements this is pretty pretty unprecedented what should they look for what are the if you at the point of someone to 11 point data point within your world that's going to get their attention and have them dive in deep what should they look at if they're having issues with their applications today if they're hearing about their application issues first from their customers and not by themselves they should be looking at our solutions to see how they can get ahead of the customers and that's what that's one precise message they can take back