>>no real filter and that kind of stuff. But you're also an entrepreneur, right? And you know the business, you've been in software, you detect business. I'm instructing you get a lot of pictures, this entertainment business on our show, we're a bubble. We don't do a lot of tech deals that were talking because it's boring tv tech people love tech consumers love the benefit of text. No consumer opens up their iphone and says, oh my gosh, I love the technology behind my, what's it been like being on the shark tank? You know, filming is fun and hang out just fun and it's fun to be a celebrity at first your head gets really big and you get a really good tables at restaurants and who says texas has got a little possessed more skin in the game today in charge of his destiny. Great robert Herjavec. No, these two stars cube alumni >>welcome back to the cubes coverage of A W. S. Public sector seven. I'm john for your host of the cube got a great segment here on healthcare startup accelerators of course. Sandy carter is co hosting media. This one Vice President Aws. She's awesome on the cuBA and jennifer Blumenthal co founder and C of one record entrepreneur, very successful. Thanks for coming on jennifer. Thank good to see you. Sandy thanks for joining me again. You >>are most welcome, >>jennifer. Before we get into the whole accelerated dynamic, just take a minute to explain what you guys do. One record. >>Sure. So one record is a digital health company that enables users to access aggregate and share their healthcare information. So what that means is we help you as a person get your data and then we also help companies who would like to have workflows were consumers in the loop to get their data. So whether they're sharing it with a provider, researcher payer. >>So, Sandy, we've talked about this amazon web services, healthcare accelerator cohort batches. What do you call cohort batches? Cohorts explain what's going on with the healthcare accelerator? >>Yeah. So, um, we decided that we would launch and partner an accelerator program and accelerator program just provides to a start up a little bit extra technical help. A little bit extra subject matter expertise and introductions to funders. And so we decided we were going to start one for health care. It's one of the biggest disruptive industries in public sector. Um, and so we weren't sure how it's gonna go. We partnered with Kids X. Kids X is part of the Los Angeles system for medical. And so we put out a call for startups and we had 427 startups, we were told on average and accelerating it's 50-100. So we were blown away 31 different countries. So it was really amazing. And then what we've been doing is down selecting and selecting that Top 10 for our first cohort. So we're going from 427 down to 10. And so obviously we looked at the founders themselves to see the quality of the leadership of the company, um the strength of their technology and the fit of the technology into the broader overall healthcare and healthcare ecosystem. And so we were thrilled that jennifer and one record was one of the top 10 start ups in this space that we chose to be in the, in the cohort. And so now we're going to take it to the six weeks intensive where we'll do training, helping them with AWS, provide them A W. S. Credits and then Kid X will also provide some of the health care uh subject matter >>expertise as well. Can I get some of those credits over here to maybe? >>Yes, you can actually, you can talk to me don you can't >>Talk to me, Jennifer, I gotta ask you. So you're an entrepreneur. So doing start doing cos it's like a roller coaster. So now to make the top 10 but also be in the area of his accelerator, it's a partnership, right? You're making a bet. What's your take on all this? >>Well, we've always been partners with a W. S. We started building on AWS in the very beginning. So when I was setting up the company a huge decision early on with infrastructure and when I saw the launch of the accelerator, I had to apply because we're at the point in the company that we're growing and part of growing is growing with the VW. So I was really excited to take advantage of that opportunity and now in the accelerator, it's more of thinking about things that we weren't thinking about the services that we can leverage to fill in the gaps within our platform so we can meet our customers where they are >>using award winning MSP cloud status city, your partners, great relationship with the ecosystem. So congratulations Sandi. What's the disruption for the healthcare? Because right now education and health care, the two top areas we're seeing and we're reporting on where cloud scale developed two point or whatever buzzword digital transformation you want to use is impacting heavily healthcare industry. There's some new realities. What's your, what's your vision, what's your view? >>Hey john before she does that, I have to give a plug to Claudius city because they just made premier partner as well, which is a huge deal. Uh and they're also serving public sector. So I just wanted to make sure that you knew that too. So you can congratulate. Go ahead, jennifer >>Well, so if I zoom in, I think about a P. I. S. Every day, that's what I think about and I think about microservices. So for me and for one record, what we think about is legislation. So 21st century Cures act says that you as a consumer have to be able to access your healthcare data from both your providers and from your players and not just your providers, but also the underlying technology vendors and H. I. E. S. H. I am and it's probably gonna extend to really anyone who plays within the healthcare ecosystem. So you're just going to see this explosion of A. P. I. S. And we're just your one of that. I mean for the payers that we went into effect on july 1st. So I mean when you think about the decentralization of healthcare where healthcare is being delivered plus an api economy, you're just going to have a whole new model developing and then throwing price transparency and you've got a whole new cake. >>I'm smiling because I love the peacocks. In fact, last night I shouldn't have tweeted this but there's a little tweet flames going on around A. P. Is being brittle and all this stuff and I said, hey developer experience about building great software apps are there for you. It's not a glue layer by itself. You got to build software around the so kind of a little preaching to the younger generation. But this health care thing is huge because think about like old school health care, it was anti ap I was also siloed. So what's your take on has the culture is changing health care because the user experience, I want my records, I want my privacy, I want to maintain everything confidential but access. That's hard. >>I think well health care to be used to just be paper was forget about a. P. I. Is it was just paper records. I think uh to me you think about uh patient journey, like a patient journey starts with booking an appointment and then everything after that is essentially an api call. So that's how I think about it is to all these micro transactions that are happening all the time and you want your data to go to your health care provider so they can give you the proper care, you want your data to go to your pair so they can pay for your care and then those two stakeholders want your data so that they can provide the right services at the right time to the right channel. And that is just a series of api calls that literally sits on a platform. >>What's interesting, I'd love to get your take on the where you think the progress bar is in the industry because Fintech has shown the way you got defy now behind a decentralized finance, health care seems to be moving on in a very accelerated rate towards that kind of concept of cloud, scale, decentralization, privacy. >>Yeah, I mean, that's a big question, what's interesting to me around that is how healthcare stakeholders are thinking about where they're providing care. So as they're buying up practices primary care specialty care and they're moving more and more outside of the brick and mortar of the health care system or partnering with your startups. That's really where I think you're going to see a larger ecosystem development, you could just look at CVS and walmart or the dollar store if they're going to be moving into health care, what does that look like? And then if you're seeking care in those settings, but then you're going to Mayo clinic or Kaiser permanente, there's so many new relationships that are part of your hair circle >>delivery is just what does that even mean now, delivery of health >>care. It's wherever you it's like the app economy you want to ride right now, you want a doctor right now, that's where we're heading its ease of use. >>This is this exciting startups, changing the game. Yes, I love it. I mean, this is what it's all about this health >>Care, this is what it's all about. And if you look at the funding right now from VCS, we're seeing so much funding pour into health care, we were just looking at some numbers and in the second quarter alone, the funding went up almost 700%. And the amount of funding that is pouring into companies like jennifer's company to really transform healthcare, 30% of it is going into telehealth. So when you talked about, you know, kind of ai at the edge, getting the right doctor the right expert at the right time, we're seeing that as a big trend in healthcare to >>well jennifer, I think the funding dynamics aside the opportunity for market total addressable market is massive when the application is being decomposed, you got front end, whether it's telemedicine, you got the different building blocks of healthcare being radically reconfigured. It's a re factoring of healthcare. Yeah, >>I think if you just think about where we're sitting today, you had to use an app to prove proof of vaccination. So this is not just national, this is a global thing to have that covid wallet. We at one record have a covid wallet. But just a couple years from now, I need more than just by covid vaccination. I need all my vaccinations. I need all my lab results. I need all my beds. It's opening the door for a new consumer behavior pattern, which is the first step to adoption for any technology. >>So somebody else covid wallet. So I need >>that was California. Did the, did a version of we just have a pen and it's pretty cool. Very handy. I should save it to my drive. But my phone, but I don't jennifer, what's the coolest thing you're working on right now because you're in the middle of all the action. >>I get very excited about the payer app is that we're working on. So I think by the end of the month we will be connected to almost to all the blues in the United States. So I'm very excited when a user comes into the one record and they're able to get their clinical data from the provider organization and then their clinical financial and formulary data from their payers because then you're getting a complete view, You're getting the records for someone who gave you care and you're getting the records from someone who paid for your care. And that's an interesting thing that's really moving towards a complete picture. So from a personal perspective that gets exciting. And then from a professional perspective, it's really working with our partners as they're using our API s to build out workflows and their applications. >>It's an api economy. I'd like to ask you to on the impact side to the patient. I hear a lot of people complaining that hey, I want to bring my records to the doctor and I want to have my own control of my own stuff. A lot of times, some doctors don't even know other historical data points about a patient that could open up a diagnosis and, or care >>or they can't even refer you to a doctor. Most doctors really only refer within a network of people that they know having a provider directory that allows doctors refer, having the data from different doctors outside of their, you know, I didn't really allows people to start thinking beyond just their little box. >>Cool. Well, great to have you on and congratulations on being in the top 10 saying this is a wonderful example of how the ecosystem where you got cloud city, your MSP. You mentioned the shout out to them jerry Miller and his team by working together the cloud gives you advantages. So I have to ask, we look at amazon cloud as an entrepreneur. It's kind of a loaded question, but I'm going to ask it. I love it. >>You always do it >>when you look at amazon, what do you see as opportunities as an entrepreneur? Because I'll see the easy ones. They have computing everything else. But like what's the, what does cloud do for you as an entrepreneur? What does it, what does it make you do? >>Yeah. So for been working with jerry since the beginning for me when I think about it, it's really the growth of our company. So when we start building, we really just thinking about it from a monolithic build and we move to microservices and amazon has been there every step of the way to support us as that. And now, you know, the things that I'm interested in are specifically health lake and anything that's NLP related that we could plug into our solution for when we get data from different sources that are coming in really unstructured formats and making it structured so that it's searchable for people and amazon does that for us with their services that we can add into the applications. >>Yeah, we announced that data health like and july it has a whole set of templates for analytics, focused on health care as well as hip hop compliance out of the box as well. >>The I think I think that's what's important is people used to think application first. Now it's creating essentially a data lake, then analytics and then what applications you build on top of that. And that's how our partners think about it and that's how we try and service them using amazon as our problem. So >>you're honing in on the value of the data and how that conflicts and then work within the whatever application requests might come >>in. Yes, >>it's interesting. You know, we had an event last month and jerry Chen from Greylock partners came on and gave a talk called castles in the cloud. He's gonna be cute before. He's a, he's a veces, they talk about moats and competitive manage so having a moat, The old school perimeter moz how cloud destroyed that. He's like, no, now the castles are in the cloud, he pointed snowflake basically data warehouse in the cloud red shifts there too. But they can be successful. And that's how the cloud, you could actually build value, sustainable value in the cloud. If you think that way of re factoring not just hosting a huge, huge, huge thing. >>I think the only thing he, this was customer service because health care is still very personal. So it's always about how you interact with the end user and how you can help me get to where they need to be going >>and what do you see that going? Because that's, that's a good point. >>I think that is a huge opportunity for any new company that wants to enter healthcare, customer service as a service in health care for all the different places that health care is going to be delivered. Maybe there's a company that I don't know about, but when they come out, I'd like to meet them. >>Yeah, I mean, I can't think of one cover that can think of right now. This is what I would say is great customer service for health care. >>And if there is one out there contacted me because I want to talk to you about AWS. >>Yeah. And you need the app from one record that make it all >>happen. That's where Omni channel customer service across all health care entities. Yeah, that's >>a great billion dollar idea for someone listening to our show right now. >>Right, alright. So saying they had to give you the opportunity to talk more because this is a great example of how the world's very agile. What's the next step for the AWS Healthcare accelerator? Are there more accelerators? Do you do it by vertical? >>What happens next? So, with the healthcare accelerator, this was our first go at the accelerator. So, this is our first set of cohorts, Of course, all 427 companies are going to get some help from a W. S. as well. We also you'll love this john We also did a space accelerator. Make sure you ask Clint about that. So we have startups that are synthesizing oxygen on mars to sending an outpost box to the moon. I mean, it's crazy what these startups are doing. Um, and then the third accelerator we started was around clean energy. So sustainability, we sold that one out to, we had folks from 66 different countries participate in that one. So these have been really successful for us. So it reinvent. When we talk again, we'll be announcing a couple of others. So right now we've got healthcare, space, clean energy and we'll be announcing a couple other accelerators moving forward. >>You know, it's interesting, jennifer the pandemic has changed even our ability to get stories. Just more stories out there now. So you're seeing kind of remote hybrid connections, ap ideas, whether it's software or remote interviews or remote connections. There's more stories being told out there with digital transformation. I mean there wasn't that many before pandemic has changed the landscape because let's face it, people were hiding some really bad projects behind metrics. But when you pull the pandemic back and you go, hey, everyone's kind of emperors got no clothes on. Those are bad projects. Those are good projects that cloud investment worked or I didn't have a cloud investment. They were pretty much screwed at that point. So this is now a new reality of like value, you can't show me value. >>It's crazy to me when I meet people who tell me like we want to move to the cloud of like, why are you not on the cloud? Like this really just blows my life. Like I don't understand why you have on prem or while you did start on the cloud, this is more for larger organizations, but younger organizations, you know, the first thing you have to do, it's set up that environment. >>Yeah. And then now with the migration plans and seeing here, uh whereas education or health care or other verticals, you've got, now you've got containers to give you that compatibility and then you've got kubernetes and you've got microservices, you've got land. Uh I mean, come on, that's the perfect storm innovation. There's no excuses in my opinion. So, you know, if you're out there and you're not leveraging it, then you're probably gonna be out of business. That's my philosophy. Thank you for coming up. Okay. Sandy, thank you. Thank you, john Okay. Any of his coverage here, summit here in D. C. I'm john ferrier. Thanks for watching. Mm >>mm mm mhm. I have been in the software and technology industry for over 12 years now, so I've had >>the opportunity

[Music] live from cambridge massachusetts extracting the signal from the noise it's the cube covering the MIT chief data officer and information quality symposium now your host dave Volante and paul Gillett hi buddy welcome back to Cambridge Massachusetts we're at MIT Paul Gillan and myself are here for two days and we're really pleased to have sandy Pentland on he's the director of MIT Media labs entrepreneurship program just coming off a keynote mr. Alex sandy Pentland Spellman thanks for coming with you how'd you get that name sandy was that the color you know my dad was named Alex too so I had to get the diminutive so Alexander turns into Zander or Sasha or sandy ah excellent so man it's stuck so we learned from your keynote today that like your mom said hey if every other kid jumps off the bridge do you and the answer should be yes why is that well if your other friends or presumably as rational as you and have same sort of values as you and if they're doing something that looks crazy they must have a piece of information you don't like maybe Godzilla is coming bridges come and it really is time to get off but and so so while it's used as a metaphor for doing the irrational things it's actually shows that using your social context can be most rational because it's a way of getting information that you don't otherwise have so you broke down your talk to chief data officers and new types of analysis smarter organizations smarter networks and then really interesting new new architecture if we could sort of break those down sure you talked about sort of networks not individual nodes as really should be the focus to understand behavior can you unpack that a little well it's a little bit like the bridge or metaphor you know a lot of what we learn a lot of our behavior comes from watching other people we're not even conscious of it but you know if everybody else starts you know wearing a certain sort of shoe or or you know acting in a certain or using a phrase in business like all these new sort of buzz phrases like oh you have to - because it's to fit in it means something it's it's part of being hyper formants and being part of your group but that's not in data analytics today today what they look at is just your personal properties not what you're exposed to and the group that you're part of so they would look at the guy on the bridge and they say he's not going to jump because he doesn't have that information but on the other hand if all of other people who like him are making a different decision he probably is going to jump and your research has been you dig into organizations and you've found the relationship between productivity and this type of analysis has been pretty substantial very substantive offenses a ssin and outside of the organization dealing with customers so people focus on things like personality history various sort of training things like that what we find is compared to the pattern of interaction with other people so who do you talk to when and what situations those other factors are tiny they're often a whole order of magnitude less important than just do you talk to all the people in your group do you talk outside of your group do if you violate the org chart and talk to other people if you do you're almost certainly one of the high productivity high innovation people so what what impact does this have or were the implications of this on organizations which historically have been have been highly Madonn hierarchies reporting structures all of these institutions that we evolved in the post-world War two ERA is this working against their productivity well what they did is is they set some simple rules in that they could deal with and wrap their head around but what we find is that those simple rules are exactly the opposite of what you need for innovation and because really what they're doing is they're enforcing silos they're enforcing atomization of the work and everybody talks about we need to be more fluid we need to be more innovative we need to be able to move faster and what that requires is better communication habits and so what we find when we measure the communication habits is that that's exactly right better communication habits lead to more innovative organizations what's really amazing is almost no organization does it so people don't know does everybody talk to everybody in this group do they talk outside of the group there's no graphic there's no visualization and when you give a group a visualization of their pattern of organization of communication they change it and they become more innovative they become more productive I'm sure you're familiar with holacracy this idea that of doing away with with organizational boundaries and sort of do titles and sure everybody talks to everyone is that in your view a better way to structure an organization think that's too extreme but it's headed in the right direction I mean so what we're talking first of all people try to do this without any data so you know everybody's the same well everybody really isn't the same and how would you know if you're behaving as well as the same as other people or I mean there's no data so so what I'm suggesting is something that's sort of halfway between the two yeah you can have leaders you can have organization in there but you also have to have good flow of ideas and what that means is you have to make talking outside your org chart a value it's something you're rewarded for it means that including everybody in the loop in your organization is something you ought to be rewarded for and of course that requires data so the sorts of things we do with peoples we make displays could just be piece of paper that shows the patterns of communication and we give it to everybody and you know what people actually know what to do with it when you give it to them they say well gee you know this group of people is all talking to each other but they're not talking to that group maybe they ought to talk to each other it's that simple but in the lack of data you can't feel so you instrumented people essentially with let's badges and you could measure conversations at the watercooler yeah they're their frequency their duration not the content not the content just that's the activity just is it happening right and is it happening between groups just just people from this group go to that other groups water cooler stuff like that and that actually is enough to really make a substantial difference in the corporation and you gave an example of you were able to predict trending stories on Twitter better than the internal mechanism and Twitter did I understand that Kerina so what we've done by studying organizations like this and coming up with these sort of rules of how people behave so the notion that people learn from each other and that it's the patterns of communication that matter you can encode that along with machine learning and suddenly you get something that looks like machine learning but in many ways it's more powerful and more reliable and so we have a spin-out called Endor and what that does is it lets your average guy who can use a spreadsheet do something that's really competitive with the best machine learning groups in the world and that's pretty exciting because everybody has these reams of data but what they don't have is a whole bunch of PhDs who can study it for six months and and come up with a machine learning algorithm to do it they have a bunch of guys that are smart know the business but they don't know the machine learning so it endured doesn't supply something like a spreadsheet to be able to allow the normal guy to do as good as the machine learning guys there's a lot of focus right now on anticipating predicting customer behavior better a lot of us been focused on on individuals understanding individuals better is that wrongheaded I mean should marketers be looking more at this group theory and treating customers more as buckets of similar behaviors it's not it's not buckets but treating people as individuals is is a mistake because while people do have individual preferences most of those preferences are learned from other people it's keeping up with the Jones it's fitting in its it's learning what the best practice is so you can predict people better from the company they keep than you can from their demographics always virtually every single time you can do better from the company they keep than from the standard sort of data so what that means is when you do analysis you need to look at the relationships between people and at one level it's sort of obvious you analyze somebody personally without knowing something about their relationships right about you know the type of things they do the places they go those are important but they're usually not in the data and what I find is I do this with a lot of big organizations and what I find is you look at their data analytics it's all based on individuals and it's not based on the context to those individuals absolutely I want to ask you further about that because when I think of the surveys that I fill out they're always about my personal preference Yahoo I want to do I can't remember ever filling out a survey that asked me about what my peer group does are you saying that those are the questions we should be asking yeah exactly right and of course you want to get data about that you want to know if if you go to these locations all the time to go to that restaurant you go to this sort of entertainment who else goes there what are they by what's trending in your group because it's not the general population and these not necessary people I know but they're people I identify with Yammer haps that's why I go to certain restaurants not because my friends go there but because people who I aspire to be like yeah there yeah and and the other way around you go there and you say well gosh these other people are like me because they go here too and I see that they're you know wearing different sort of clothes or they're by or the simplest thing you go to restaurants you see other people all buying the mushi yes maybe I should try the mushi I usually don't like it but seems to work well and this is I like this restaurant and everybody else who comes here likes it so I'll try it right it's that simple so it's important to point out we're talking about the predictive analytics Capas they're probably people watching might say this Sandi's crazy we mean we don't want it personalized we want to personalize the customer experience still I'm presuming sure but when we're talking about predictive analytics you're saying the the community the peer group is a much better predictor than the individual that's right yeah okay so I want to come back to the the org chart these are you saying that org charts shouldn't necessarily change but the incentives should or your previous thing to do is you have an org chart but the incentives that are across the entire organization is good communication within the box you're in and good communication outside of the box and to put those incentives in place you need to have data you need to be able to have some way of estimating does everybody talk to each other do they talk to the rest of the organization and there's a variety of ways you can do that we do it with little badges we do it by analyzing phone call data email is not so good because email is not really a social relationship it's just this this little formal thing you do often but by using things like the badges like the phone calls surveys for that matter right you can give people feedback about are they communicating in the right way are they communicating with other parts of the organization and by visualizing that to people they'll begin to do the right thing you had this notion of network tuning oh you don't want an insufficiently diverse network but you don't want a network that's too dense you might find the sweet spot in the middle desert how do you actually implement that that tuning well the first thing is is you have to measure okay you have to know how dense is the social interaction the communication pattern because if you don't know that there's nothing to - right and then what you want to ask is you want to ask the signal property of something being two dances the same ideas go around then around and around so you look at the graph that you get from this data and you ask you know this Joe talked to Bob talk to Mary talk to Joe talk to you know is it full of cycles like that and if it's too full of cycles then that's a problem right because it's the same people talking to each other same ideas going around and there's some nice mathematical formulas for major in it they're sort of hard to put into English but it has to do with if you look at the flow of ideas are you getting a sufficiently diverse set of ideas coming to you or is it just the same people all talking to each other so are you sort of cut off from the rest of the world in your book social physics you talk about rewards and incentives isms and one of the things that struck me as you say that that rewards that people are actually more motivated by rewards for others than for themselves correct me if I'm wrong if paraphrasing you wrong there but but there's but but rewarding the group or or doing something good for somebody else is actually a powerful incentive is it is that the true the case well you said it almost right so so if you want to change behavior these social incentives are more powerful than financial incentives so if you have everybody in a group let's say and people are rewarded by the behavior of the other people in the group what will they do well they'll talk to the other people about doing the right thing because their reward my reward depends on your behavior so I'm gonna talk to you about it okay and your reward depends on it you'll talk and I don't know so what we're doing is we're creating much more communication around this problem and social pressure because you know if you don't do it you're screwing me and and you know I may not be a big thing but you're gonna think twice about that whereas some small financial award usually it's not such a big thing for people so if you think people talk a lot about you know persona persona marketing when I first met John Fourier he had this idea of affinity rank which was his version of you know peer group PageRank hmm do you do you hear a lot about you know get a lot of questions about persona persona marketing and and what does your research show in terms of how we should be appealing to that persona so sorry good questions about that some time and I don't know what he really originally intended but the way people often imply it is very static you have a particular persona that's fixed for all parts of your life well that's not true I mean you could be a baseball coach for your kid and a banker during the day and a member of a church and those are three different personas and what defines those personas it's the group that you're interacting with it's it's the the people you learn with and try and fit in so your persona is a variable thing and the thing that's the key to it is what are the groups that you're you're interacting with so if I analyzed your groups of interactions I'd see three different clusters I'd see the baseball one I'd say the banking one I'd see the church group one and then I would know that you have three personas and I could tell which one you're in typically by seeing who you're spending time with right now is the risk of applying this idea of behaviors influenced by groups is there the risk of falling over into profiling and essentially treating people anticipating behaviors based upon characteristics that may not be indicative of how any individual might act back credit alcoholics as you example right I don't get a job because people like people who are similar to me tend to be alcoholics let's say this is different though so this is not people who are similar to you if you hang out with alcoholics all the time then they're really eyes are good on that you're an alcoholic it may not be yes and there is a risk of over identifying or or extrapolating but it's different than people like me I mean if you go to the you know the dingy bars were beers or a buck and everybody gets wasted and you do that repeatedly you're talking about behaviors rather than characteristics behaviors rather than characteristics right I mean you know if you drink a lot maybe you drink a lot so we have a question from the crowd so it says real time makes persona very difficult yeah so it was come back to furriers premise was I was Twitter data you know such is changing very rapidly so are there social platforms that you see that can inform in real time to help us sort of get a better understanding of persona and affinity group affinity well there are data sources that do that right so first as if I look at telephone data or credit card data even for that matter sure this geo-located I can ask but what sort of people buy here or what sort of people are in this bar or restaurant and I can look at their demographics and where they go to I showed an example of that in San Francisco using data from San Francisco so there is this data which means that any app that's interested in it that has sufficient breadth and although sufficient adoption can do these sorts of analyses can you give an example of how you're working with the many organizations now I'm sure you can't name them but can you give an example of how you're applying these principles practically now whether it's in law enforcement or in consumer marketing how are you putting these to work well there's a bunch of different things that that go together with this view of you know it's the flow of ideas that's the important thing not the demographics so talk about behavior change and we're working with a small country to change their traffic safety by enrolling people in small groups where you know the benefit I get for driving right depends on your safety and we're good buddies we know that that's how you sign up sign up with your buddies and what that means is I'm going to talk to you about your driving if you're driving in a dangerous way and that we've seen in small experiments is a lot more effective than giving you points on your driver's license or discount on your insurance the social relationships so so that's an example another example is we're beginning a project to look at unemployment and what we see is is that people have a hard time getting re-employed don't have diverse enough social networks and it sounds kind of common sense but they don't physically get out enough compared to the people that do get jobs so what's the obvious thing well you encouraged them to get out more you make it easier for them to get out more so those are some examples when you talk about health care what you can do is you can say well look you know I don't know particular things you're doing but based on the behavior that you show right and the behavior of the people you hang with you may be at much higher risk of diabetes and it's not any particular behavior this is the way medical stuff is always pitched is you know it's this behavior that beer every combination of things all right and so you're not really aware that you're doing anything bad but if all your buds are at risk of it then you probably are too because you're probably doing a lot of the same sort of behaviors and medicine is a place where people are willing to give up some of the privacy because the consequences are so important so we're looking at people who are interested in personalized medicine and are willing to you know share their data about where they go and what they spend time doing in order to get statistics back from the people they spend time with about what are the risk factors they pick up from the people around them and the behaviors they engage in um your message this to the cdos today was you know you were sort of joking you're measuring that right and a lot of times they weren't a lot of the non-intuitive things your research has found so I wanna talk about the data and access to the data and how the CBO can you know affect change in their organization a lot of the data lives in silos I mean if they certainly think of social data Facebook LinkedIn yeah Twitter you mentioned credit card data is that a problem or is data becoming more accessible through api's or is it still just sort of a battle to get that data architecture running well it's a it's a battle and in fact actually it's a political and very passionate battle and it revolves around who controls the data and privacy is a big part of that so one of the messages is that to be able to get really ditch data sources you have to engage with the customer a lot so people are more than willing our research we've set up you know entire cities where we've changed the rules and we've found that people are more than willing to volunteer very detailed personal data under two conditions one is they have to know that it's safe so you're not reselling it you're handling it in a secure way it's not going to get out in some way and the other is that they get value for it and they can see the value so it's not spreading out and they're part of the discussion so you know you want more personalized medicine people are willing to share right because it's important to them or for their family you know if you want to share we're willing to share very personal stuff about their kids they would never do that but if it results in the kid getting a better education more opportunity yeah they're absolutely willing so that leads to a great segue into enigma yeah you talked about enigma as a potential security layer for the internet but also potential privacy yeah solution so talk about enigma where it's at yeah what it is where it's at and how it potentially could permeate yeah so we've been building architectures and working with this sort of problem this conundrum basically datas and silos people feel paranoid and probably correctly about their data leaky now companies don't have access to data don't know what to do with it and a lot of it has to do with safe sharing another aspect of this problem is cybersecurity you're getting increasing the amount of attacks done stuff bad for companies bad for people it's just going to get worse and we actually know what the answers to these things are the answers our data is encrypted all the time everywhere you do the computation on encrypted data you never transmit it you never unencrypted it to be able to do things we also know that in terms of control of the data is possible to build fairly simple permission mechanisms so that you know the computer just won't share it in the wrong places and if it does you know skyrockets go up and the cop scum you can build systems like that today but the part that's never been able never allowed that to happen is you need to keep track of a lot of things in a way that's not hackable you need to know that somebody doesn't just short-circuit it or take it out the back and what's interesting is the mechanisms that are in Bitcoin give you exactly that power so you whatever you feel about Bitcoin you know it's speculative bubble or whatever the blockchain which is part of it is this open ledger that is unhackable and and has the following characteristics that's amazing it's called trustless what that means is you can work with a bunch of crooks and still know that the ledger that you're keeping is correct because it doesn't require trusting people to work with them it's something where everybody has to agree to be able to get things and it works it works in Bitcoin at scale over the whole world and so what we've done is adapted that technology to be able to build a system called enigma which takes data in an encrypted form computes on it in an encrypted form transmits it according to the person's permissions and only that way in an encrypted form and you know it provides this layer of security and privacy that we've never had before there have been some projects that come close to this but know we're pretty excited about this and and what I think you're going to see is you're going to see some of the big financial institutions trying to use it among themselves some of the big logistics some of the big medical things trying to use it in in hotspots where they have real problems but the hope is is that it gets spread among the general population so it becomes quite literally the privacy and security level that doesn't have Warren Buffett might be right that it might fail as a currency but the technology has really inspired some new innovations that's right so so it's essentially a distributed it's not a walled garden it's a distributed black box that's what you're describing you never exposed the data that's right you don't need a trusted third party that's getting attacked that's right nobody has to stamp that this is correct because the moment you do that first of all other people are controlling you and the second thing is is there a point of attack so it gets rid of that trusted third party centralization makes it distributed you can have again a bunch of bad actors in the system it doesn't hurt it's peer-to-peer where you have to have 51% of the people being bad before things really go bad how do you solve the problem of performing calculations on encrypted data because they're classic techniques actually it's been known for over 20 years how to do that but there are two pieces missing one piece is it wasn't efficient it scaled really poorly and what we did is came up with a way of solving that by making it essentially multi scale so it's it's a distributed solution for this that brings the cost down to something that's linear in the number of elements which is a real change and the second is keeping track of all of the stuff in a way that's secure it's fine to have an addition that's secure you know but if that isn't better than a whole system that secure it doesn't do you any good and so that's where the blockchain comes in it gives you this accounting mechanism for knowing which computations are being done who has access to them what the keys are things like that so Google glass was sort of incubated in MIT Media labs and well before yeah my group you go right in your group and yeah it didn't take off me because it's just not cool it looks kind of goofy but now enigma has a lot of potential solving a huge problem are you can open-source it what do you yeah it's an open-source system we hope to get more people involved in it and right now we're looking for some test beds to show how well it works and make sure that all the things are dotted and crossed and so forth and where can people learn more about it oh go to a nygma dot media dot mit.edu all right sandy we're way over our time so obviously you were interesting so thanks keep right there buddy Paul and I we right back with our next guest we're live from see this is the cube right back [Music]