>> From theCUBE Studios in Palo Alto, in Boston bringing you Data Driven Insights from theCUBE and ETR. This is Breaking Analysis with Dave Vellante. >> In the pre-cloud era hardware companies would run benchmarks, showing how database and or application performance ran better on their systems relative to competitors or previous generation boxes. And they would make a big deal out of it. And the independent software vendors, you know they'd do a little golf clap if you will, in the form of a joint press release it became a game of leaprog amongst hardware competitors. That was pretty commonplace over the years. The Dell Snowflake Deal underscores that the value proposition between hardware companies and ISVs is changing and has much more to do with distribution channels, volumes and the amount of data that lives On-Prem in various storage platforms. For cloud native ISVs like Snowflake they're realizing that despite their Cloud only dogma they have to grit their teeth and deal with On-premises data or risk getting shut out of evolving architectures. Hello and welcome to this week's Wikibon Cube Insights powered by ETR. In this breaking analysis, we unpack what little is known about the Snowflake announcement from Dell Technologies World and discuss the implications of a changing Cloud landscape. We'll also share some new data for Cloud and Database platforms from ETR that shows Snowflake has actually entered the Earth's orbit when it comes to spending momentum on its platform. Now, before we get into the news I want you to listen to Frank's Slootman's answer to my question as to whether or not Snowflake would ever architect the platform to run On-Prem because it's doable technically, here's what he said, play the clip >> Forget it, this will only work in the Public Cloud. Because it's, this is how the utility model works, right. I think everybody is coming through this realization, right? I mean, excuses are running out at this point. You know, we think that it'll, people will come to the Public Cloud a lot sooner than we will ever come to the Private Cloud. It's not that we can't run a private Cloud. It's just diminishes the potential and the value that we bring. >> So you may be asking yourselves how do you square that circle? Because basically the Dell Snowflake announcement is about bringing Snowflake to the private cloud, right? Or is it let's get into the news and we'll find out. Here's what we know at Dell Technologies World. One of the more buzzy announcements was the, by the way this was a very well attended vet event. I should say about I would say 8,000 people by my estimates. But anyway, one of the more buzzy announcements was Snowflake can now run analytics on Non-native Snowflake data that lives On-prem in a Dell object store Dell's ECS to start with. And eventually it's software defined object store. Here's Snowflake's clark, Snowflake's Clark Patterson describing how it works this past week on theCUBE. Play the clip. The way it works is I can now access Non-native Snowflake data using what materialized views, external tables How does that work? >> Some combination of the, all the above. So we've had in Snowflake, a capability called External Tables, which you refer to, it goes hand in hand with this notion of external stages. Basically there's a through the combination of those two capabilities, it's a metadata layer on data, wherever it resides. So customers have actually used this in Snowflake for data lake data outside of Snowflake in the Cloud, up until this point. So it's effectively an extension of that functionality into the Dell On-Premises world, so that we can tap into those things. So we use the external stages to expose all the metadata about what's in the Dell environment. And then we build external tables in Snowflake. So that data looks like it is in Snowflake. And then the experience for the analyst or whomever it is, is exactly as though that data lives in the Snowflake world. >> So as Clark explained, this capability of External tables has been around in the Cloud for a while, mainly to suck data out of Cloud data lakes. Snowflake External Tables use file level metadata, for instance, the name of the file and the versioning so that it can be queried in a stage. A stage is just an external location outside of Snowflake. It could be an S3 bucket or an Azure Blob and it's soon will be a Dell object store. And in using this feature, the Dell looks like it lives inside of Snowflake and Clark essentially, he's correct to say to an analyst that looks exactly like the data is in Snowflake, but uh, not exactly the data's read only which means you can't do what are called DML operations. DML stands for Data Manipulation Language and allows for things like inserting data into tables or deleting and modifying existing data. But the data can be queried. However, the performance of those queries to External Tables will almost certainly be slower. Now users can build things like materialized views which are going to speed things up a bit, but at the end of the day, it's going to run faster than the Cloud. And you can be almost certain that's where Snowflake wants it to run, but some organizations can't or won't move data into the Cloud for a variety of reasons, data sovereignty, compliance security policies, culture, you know, whatever. So data can remain in place On-prem, or it can be moved into the Public Cloud with this new announcement. Now, the compute today presumably is going to be done in the Public Cloud. I don't know where else it's going to be done. They really didn't talk about the compute side of things. Remember, one of Snowflake's early innovations was to separate compute from storage. And what that gave them is you could more efficiently scale with unlimited resources when you needed them. And you could shut off the compute when you don't need us. You didn't have to buy, and if you need more storage you didn't have to buy more compute and vice versa. So everybody in the industry has copied that including AWS with Redshift, although as we've reported not as elegantly as Snowflake did. RedShift's more of a storage tiering solution which minimizes the compute required but you can't really shut it off. And there are companies like Vertica with Eon Mode that have enabled this capability to be done On-prem, you know, but of course in that instance you don't have unlimited elastic compute scale on-Prem but with solutions like Dell Apex and HPE GreenLake, you can certainly, you can start to simulate that Cloud elasticity On-prem. I mean, it's not unlimited but it's sort of gets you there. According to a Dell Snowflake joint statement, the companies the quote, the companies will pursue product integrations and joint go to market efforts in the second half of 2022. So that's a little vague and kind of benign. It's not really clear when this is going to be available based on that statement from the two first, but, you know, we're left wondering will Dell develop an On-Prem compute capability and enable queries to run locally maybe as part of an extended apex offering? I mean, we don't know really not sure there's even a market for that but it's probably a good bet that again, Snowflake wants that data to land in the Snowflake data Cloud kind of makes you wonder how this deal came about. You heard Sloop on earlier Snowflake has always been pretty dogmatic about getting data into its native snowflake format to enable the best performance as we talked about but also data sharing and governance. But you could imagine that data architects they're building out their data mesh we've reported on this quite extensively and their data fabric and those visions around that. And they're probably telling Snowflake, Hey if you want to be a strategic partner of ours you're going to have to be more inclusive of our data. That for whatever reason we're not putting in your Cloud. So Snowflake had to kind of hold its nose and capitulate. Now the good news is it further opens up Snowflakes Tam the total available market. It's obviously good marketing posture. And ultimately it provides an on ramp to the Cloud. And we're going to come back to that shortly but let's look a little deeper into what's happening with data platforms and to do that we'll bring in some ETR data. Now, let me just say as companies like Dell, IBM, Cisco, HPE, Lenovo, Pure and others build out their hybrid Clouds. The cold hard fact is not only do they have to replicate the Cloud Operating Model. You will hear them talk about that a lot, but they got to do that. So it, and that's critical from a user experience but in order to gain that flywheel momentum they need to build a robust ecosystem that goes beyond their proprietary portfolios. And, you know, honestly they're really not even in the first inning most companies and for the likes of Snowflake to sort of flip this, they've had to recognize that not everything is moving into the Cloud. Now, let's bring up the next slide. One of the big areas of discussion at Dell Tech World was Apex. That's essentially Dell's nascent as a service offering. Apex is infrastructure as a Service Cloud On-prem and obviously has the vision of connecting to the Cloud and across Clouds and out to the Edge. And it's no secret that database is one of the most important ingredients of infrastructure as a service generally in Cloud Infrastructure specifically. So this chart here shows the ETR data for data platforms inside of Dell accounts. So the beauty of ETR platform is you can cut data a million different ways. So we cut it. We said, okay, give us the Cloud platforms inside Dell accounts, how are they performing? Now, this is a two dimensional graphic. You got net score or spending momentum on the vertical axis and what ETR now calls Overlap formally called Market Share which is a measure of pervasiveness in the survey. That's on the horizontal axis that red dotted line at 40% represents highly elevated spending on the Y. The table insert shows the raw data for how the dots are positioned. Now, the first call out here is Snowflake. According to ETR quote, after 13 straight surveys of astounding net scores, Snowflake has finally broken the trend with its net score dropping below the 70% mark among all respondents. Now, as you know, net score is measured by asking customers are you adding the platform new? That's the lime green in the bar that's pointing from Snowflake in the graph and or are you increasing spend by 6% or more? That's the forest green is spending flat that's the gray is you're spend decreasing by 6% or worse. That's the pinkish or are you decommissioning the platform bright red which is essentially zero for Snowflake subtract the reds from the greens and you get a net score. Now, what's somewhat interesting is that snowflakes net score overall in the survey is 68 which is still huge, just under 70%, but it's net score inside the Dell account base drops to the low sixties. Nonetheless, this chart tells you why Snowflake it's highly elevated spending momentum combined with an increasing presence in the market over the past two years makes it a perfect initial data platform partner for Dell. Now and in the Ford versus Ferrari dynamic. That's going on between the likes of Dell's apex and HPE GreenLake database deals are going to become increasingly important beyond what we're seeing with this recent Snowflake deal. Now noticed by the way HPE is positioned on this graph with its acquisition of map R which is now part of HPE Ezmeral. But if these companies want to be taken seriously as Cloud players, they need to further expand their database affinity to compete ideally spinning up databases as part of their super Clouds. We'll come back to that that span multiple Clouds and include Edge data platforms. We're a long ways off from that. But look, there's Mongo, there's Couchbase, MariaDB, Cloudera or Redis. All of those should be on the short list in my view and why not Microsoft? And what about Oracle? Look, that's to be continued on maybe as a future topic in a, in a Breaking Analysis but I'll leave you with this. There are a lot of people like John Furrier who believe that Dell is playing with fire in the Snowflake deal because he sees it as a one way ticket to the Cloud. He calls it a one way door sometimes listen to what he said this past week. >> I would say that that's a dangerous game because we've seen that movie before, VMware and AWS. >> Yeah, but that we've talked about this don't you think that was the right move for VMware? >> At the time, but if you don't nurture the relationship AWS will take all those customers ultimately from VMware. >> Okay, so what does the data say about what John just said? How is VMware actually doing in Cloud after its early missteps and then its subsequent embracing of AWS and other Clouds. Here's that same XY graphic spending momentum on the Y and pervasiveness on the X and the same table insert that plots the dots and the, in the breakdown of Dell's net score granularity. You see that at the bottom of the chart in those colors. So as usual, you see Azure and AWS up and to the right with Google well behind in a distant third, but still in the mix. So very impressive for Microsoft and AWS to have both that market presence in such elevated spending momentum. But the story here in context is that the VMware Cloud on AWS and VMware's On-Prem Cloud like VMware Cloud Foundation VCF they're doing pretty well in the market. Look, at HPE, gaining some traction in Cloud. And remember, you may not think HPE and Dell and VCF are true Cloud but these are customers answering the survey. So their perspective matters more than the purest view. And the bad news is the Dell Cloud is not setting the world on fire from a momentum standpoint on the vertical axis but it's above the line of zero and compared to Dell's overall net score of 20 you could see it's got some work to do. Okay, so overall Dell's got a pretty solid net score to you know, positive 20, as I say their Cloud perception needs to improve. Look, Apex has to be the Dell Cloud brand not Dell reselling VMware. And that requires more maturity of Apex it's feature sets, its selling partners, its compensation models and it's ecosystem. And I think Dell clearly understands that. I think they're pretty open about that. Now this includes partners that go beyond being just sellers has to include more tech offerings in the marketplace. And actually they got to build out a marketplace like Cloud Platform. So they got a lot of work to do there. And look, you've got Oracle coming up. I mean they're actually kind of just below the magic 40% in the line which is pro it's pretty impressive. And we've been telling you for years, you can hate Oracle all you want. You can hate its price, it's closed system all of that it's red stack shore. You can say it's legacy. You can say it's old and outdated, blah, blah, blah. You can say Oracle is irrelevant in trouble. You are dead wrong. When it comes to mission critical workloads. Oracle is the king of the hill. They're a founder led company that knows exactly what it's doing and they're showing Cloud momentum. Okay, the last point is that while Microsoft AWS and Google have major presence as shown on the X axis. VMware and Oracle now have more than a hundred citations in the survey. You can see that on the insert in the right hand, right most column. And IBM had better keep the momentum from last quarter going, or it won't be long before they get passed by Dell and HP in Cloud. So look, John might be right. And I would think Snowflake quietly agrees that this Dell deal is all about access to Dell's customers and their data. So they can Hoover it into the Snowflake Data Cloud but the data right now, anyway doesn't suggest that's happening with VMware. Oh, by the way, we're keeping an eye close eye on NetApp who last September ink, a similar deal to VMware Cloud on AWS to see how that fares. Okay, let's wrap with some closing thoughts on what this deal means. We learned a lot from the Cloud generally in AWS, specifically in two pizza teams, working backwards, customer obsession. We talk about flywheel all the time and we've been talking today about marketplaces. These have all become common parlance and often fundamental narratives within strategic plans investor decks and customer presentations. Cloud ecosystems are different. They take both competition and partnerships to new heights. You know, when I look at Azure service offerings like Apex, GreenLake and similar services and I see the vendor noise or hear the vendor noise that's being made around them. I kind of shake my head and ask, you know which movie were these companies watching last decade? I really wish we would've seen these initiatives start to roll out in 2015, three years before AWS announced Outposts not three years after but Hey, the good news is that not only was Outposts a wake up call for the On-Prem crowd but it's showing how difficult it is to build a platform like Outposts and bring it to On-Premises. I mean, Outpost isn't currently even a rounding era in the marketplace. It really doesn't do much in terms of database support and support of other services. And, you know, it's unclear where that that is going. And I don't think it has much momentum. And so the Hybrid Cloud Vendors they've had time to figure it out. But now it's game on, companies like Dell they're promising a consistent experience between On-Prem into the Cloud, across Clouds and out to the Edge. They call it MultCloud which by the way my view has really been multi-vendor Chuck, Chuck Whitten. Who's the new co-COO of Dell called it Multi-Cloud by default. (laughing) That's really, I think an accurate description of that. I call this new world Super Cloud. To me, it's different than MultiCloud. It's a layer that runs on top of hyperscale infrastructure kind of hides the underlying complexity of the Cloud. It's APIs, it's primitives. And it stretches not only across Clouds but out to the Edge. That's a big vision and that's going to require some seriously intense engineering to build out. It's also going to require partnerships that go beyond the portfolios of companies like Dell like their own proprietary stacks if you will. It's going to have to replicate the Cloud Operating Model and to do that, you're going to need more and more deals like Snowflake and even deeper than Snowflake, not just in database. Sure, you'll need to have a catalog of databases that run in your On-Prem and Hybrid and Super Cloud but also other services that customers can tap. I mean, can you imagine a day when Dell offers and embraces a directly competitive service inside of apex. I have trouble envisioning that, you know not with their historical posture, you think about companies like, you know, Nutanix, you know, or Cisco where they really, you know those relationships cooled quite quickly but you know, look, think about it. That's what AWS does. It offers for instance, Redshift and Snowflake side by side happily and the Redshift guys they probably hate Snowflake. I wouldn't blame them, but the EC Two Folks, they love them. And Adam SloopesKy understands that ISVs like Snowflake are a key part of the Cloud ecosystem. Again, I have a hard time envisioning that occurring with Dell or even HPE, you know maybe less so with HPE, but what does this imply that the Edge will allow companies like Dell to a reach around on the Cloud and somehow create a new type of model that begrudgingly accommodates the Public Cloud but drafts of the new momentum of the Edge, which right now to these companies is kind of mostly telco and retail. It's hard to see that happening. I think it's got to evolve in a more comprehensive and inclusive fashion. What's much more likely is companies like Dell are going to substantially replicate that Cloud Operating Model for the pieces that they own pieces that they control which admittedly are big pieces of the market. But unless they're able to really tap that ecosystem magic they're not going to be able to grow much beyond their existing install bases. You take that lime green we showed you earlier that new adoption metric from ETR as an example, by my estimates, AWS and Azure are capturing new accounts at a rate between three to five times faster than Dell and HPE. And in the more mature US and mere markets it's probably more like 10 X and a major reason is because of the Cloud's robust ecosystem and the optionality and simplicity of transaction that that is bringing to customers. Now, Dell for its part is a hundred billion dollar revenue company. And it has the capability to drive that kind of dynamic. If it can pivot its partner ecosystem mindset from kind of resellers to Cloud services and technology optionality. Okay, that's it for now? Thanks to my colleagues, Stephanie Chan who helped research topics for Breaking Analysis. Alex Myerson is on the production team. Kristen Martin and Cheryl Knight and Rob Hof, on editorial they helped get the word out and thanks to Jordan Anderson for the new Breaking Analysis branding and graphics package. Remember these episodes are all available as podcasts wherever you listen. All you do is search Breaking Analysis podcasts. You could check out ETR website @etr.ai. We publish a full report every week on wikibon.com and siliconangle.com. You want to get in touch. @dave.vellente @siliconangle.com. You can DM me @dvellante. You can make a comment on our LinkedIn posts. This is Dave Vellante for the Cube Insights powered by ETR. Have a great week, stay safe, be well. And we'll see you next time. (upbeat music)

>> theCube presents Dell Technologies World, brought to you by Dell. >> Hi everyone, welcome back to Dell Technologies World 2022. You're watching theCube's coverage of this, three-day coverage wall to wall. My name is David Vellante John Furrier's here, Lisa Martin, David Nicholson. Talk of the town here is data. And one of the big announcements at the show is Snowflake and Dell partnering up, building ecosystems. Snowflake reaching into on-prem, allowing customers to actually access the Snowflake Data Cloud without moving the data or if they want to move the data they can. This is really one of the hotter announcements of the show. Martin Glynn is here, he's the Senior Director of Storage Product Management at Dell Technologies. And Clark Patterson, he's the Head of Product Marketing for Snowflake. Guys, welcome. >> Thanks for having us. >> So a lot of buzz around this and, you know, Clark, you and I have talked about the need to really extend your data vision. And this really is the first step ever you've taken on-prem. Explain the motivation for this from your customer's perspective. >> Yeah. I mean, if you step back and think about Snowflake's vision and our mission of mobilizing the world's data, it's all around trying to break down silos for however customers define what a silo is, right? So we've had a lot of success breaking down silos from a workload perspective where we've expanded the platform to be data warehousing, and data engineering, and machine learning, and data science, and all the kind of compute intensive ways that people work with us. We've also had a lot of success in our sharing capabilities and how we're breaking down silos of organizations, right? So I can share data more seamlessly within my team, I can do it across totally disparate organizations, and break down silos that way. So this partnership is really like the next leg of the stool, so to speak, where we're breaking down the silos of the the data and where the data lives ultimately, right? So up until this point, Cloud, all focus there, and now we have this opportunity with Dell to expand that and into on-premises world and people can bring all those data sets together. >> And the data target for this Martin, is Dell ECS, right? Your object store, and it's got S3 compatibility. Explain that. >> Yeah, we've actually got sort of two flavors. We'll start with ECS, which is our turnkey object storage solution. Object storage offers sort of the ultimate in flexibility, you know, potential performance, ease of use, right? Which is why it fits so well with Snowflake's mission for sort of unlocking, you know, the data within the data center. So we'll offer it to begin with ECS, and then we also recently announced our software defined object scale solution. So add even more flexibility there. >> Okay. And the clock, the way it works is I can now access non-native Snowflake data using what? Materialized views, external tables, how does that work? >> Some combination of all the above. So we've had in Snowflake a capability called external tables which we refer to, it goes hand in hand with this notion of external stages. Basically through the combination of those two capabilities, it's a metadata layer on data wherever it resides. So customers have actually used this in Snowflake for data lake data outside of Snowflake in the Cloud up until this point. So it's effectively an extension of that functionality into the Dell on-premises world, so that we can tap into those things. So we use the external stages to expose all the metadata about what's in the Dell environment. And then we build external tables in Snowflake so that data looks like it is in Snowflake. And then the experience for the analyst or whomever it is, is exactly as though that data lives in the Snowflake world. >> Okay. So for a while you've allowed non-native Snowflake data but it had to be in the Cloud. >> Correct. >> It was the first time it's on-prem, >> that's correct >> that's the innovation here. Okay. And if I want to bring it into the Cloud, can I? >> Yeah, the connection here will help in a migration sense as well, right? So that's the good thing is, it's really giving the user the choice. So we are integrating together as partners to make connection as seamless as possible. And then the end user will say like, look I've got data that needs to live on-premises, for whatever reasons, data sovereignty whatever they decide. And they can keep it there and still do the analytics in another place. But if there's a need and a desire to use this as an opportunity to migrate some of that data to Cloud, that connection between our two platforms will make that easier. >> Well, Michael always says, "Hey, it's customer choice, we're flexible." So you're cool with that? That's been the mission since we kind of came together, right? Is if our customers needed to stay in their data center, if that makes more sense from a cost perspective or, you know, a data gravity perspective, then they can do that. But we also want to help them unlock the value of that data. So if they need to copy it up to the public Cloud and take advantage of it, we're going to integrate directly with Snowflake to make that really easy to do. >> So there are engineering integrations here, obviously that's required. Can you describe what that looks like? Give us the details on when it's available. >> Sure. So it's going to be sort of second half this year that you'll see, we're demoing it this week, but the availability we second half this year. And fundamentally, it's the way Clark described it, that Snowflake will reach into our S3 interface using the standard S3 interface. We're qualifying between the way they expect that S3 interface to present the data and the way our platform works, just to ensure that there's smooth interaction between the two. So that's sort of the first simplest use case. And then the second example we gave where the customer can copy some of that data up to the public Cloud. We're basically copying between two S3 buckets and making sure that Snowflake's Snowpipe is aware that data's being made available and can easily ingest it. >> And then that just goes into a virtual warehouse- >> Exactly. >> and customer does to know or care. >> Yep Exactly. >> Yeah. >> The compute happens in Snowflake the way it does in any other manner. >> And I know you got to crawl, walk, run second half of this year, but I would imagine, okay, you're going to start with AWS, correct? And then eventually you go to other Clouds. I mean, that's going to take other technical integrations, I mean, obviously. So should we assume there's a roadmap here or is this a one and done? >> I would assume that, I mean, based on our multi-Cloud approach, that's kind of our approach at least, yeah. >> Kind of makes sense, right? I mean, that would seem to be a natural progression. My other thought was, okay, I've got operational systems. They might be transaction systems running on a on a PowerMax. >> Yeah. >> Is there a way to get the data into an object store and make that available, now that opens up even more workloads. I know you're not committing to doing that, but it just, conceptually, it seems like something a customer might want to do. >> Yeah. I, a hundred percent, agree. I mean, I think when we brought our team together we started with a blank slate. It was what's the best solution we can build. We landed on this sort of first step, but we got lots of feedback from a lot of our big joint customers about you know, this system over there, this potential integration over here, and whether it's, you know, PowerMax type systems or other file workloads with native Snowflake data types. You know, I think this is just the beginning, right? We have lots of potential here. >> And I don't think you've announced pricing, right? It's premature for that. But have you thought about, and how are you thinking about the pricing model? I mean, you're a consumption based pricing, is that kind of how this is going to work? Or is it a sort of a new pricing model or haven't you figured that out yet? >> I don't know if you've got any details on that, but from a Snowflake perspective, I would assume it's consistent with how our customers engage with us today. >> Yeah. >> And we'll offer both possibilities, right? So you can either continue with the standard, you know, sort of CapEx motion, maybe that's the most optimal for you from a cost perspective, or you can take advantage through our OpEx option, right? So you can do consumption on-prem also. >> Okay. So it could be a dual model, right? Depending on what the customer wants. If they're a Snowflake customer, obviously it's going to be consumption based, however, you guys price. What's happening, Clark, in in the market? Explain why Snowflake has so much momentum and, you know, traction in the marketplace. >> So like I spent a lot of time doing analysis on why we win and lose, core part of my role. And, you know, there's a couple of, there's really three things that come up consistently as to why people people are really excited about Snowflake platform. One is the most simplest thing of all. It feels like is just ease of use and it just works, right? And I think the way that this platform was built for the Cloud from the ground up all the way back 10 years ago, really a lot allows us to deliver that seamless experience of just like instant compute when you want it, it goes away, you know, only pay for what you use. Very few knobs to turn and things like that. And so people absolutely love that factor. The other is multi-Cloud. So, you know, there's definitely a lot of organizations out there that have a multi-Cloud strategy, and, you know, what that means to them can be highly variable, but regardless, they want to be able to interact across Clouds in some capacity. And of course we are a single platform, like literally one single interface, consistent across all the three Cloud providers that we work upon. And it gives them that flexibility to mix and match Cloud infrastructure under any Snowflake however they see fit. The last piece of it is sharing. And, you know, I think it's that ability as I kind of alluded to around like breaking down organizational silos, and allow people to be able to actually connect with each other in ways that you couldn't do before. Like, if you think about how you and I would've shared data before, I'd be like, "Hey, Dave, I'm going to unload this table into a spreadsheet and I'm going to send it over in email." And there's the whole host of issues that get introduced in that and world, now it's like instantly available. I have a lot of control over it, it's governed it's all these other things. And I can create kind of walled gardens, so to speak, of how far out I want that to go. It could be in a controlled environment of organizations that I want to collaborate with, or I can put it on our marketplace and expose it to the whole world, because I think there's a value in that. And if I choose I can monetize it, right? So those, you know, the ease of use aspect of it, absolutely, it's just a fantastic platform. The multi-Cloud aspect of it and our unique differentiation around sharing in our marketplace and monetization. >> Yeah, on the sharing front. I mean, it's now discoverable. Like if you send me an email, like what'd you call that? When did you send that email? And then the same time I can forward that to somebody else's not governed. >> Yeah. >> All right. So that just be creates a nightmare for the compliance. >> Right. Yeah. You think about how you revoke access in that situation. You just don't, right? Now I can just turn it off and you go in to run your query. >> Don't get access on that data anymore. Yeah. Okay. And then the other thing I wanted to ask you, Clark is Snowflake started really as analytics platform, simplifying data warehousing, you're moving into that world of data science, you know, the whole data lake movement, bringing those two worlds together. You know, I was talking to Ben Ward about this, maybe there's a semantic layer that helps us kind of talk between those two worlds, but you don't care, right? If it's in an object store, it can play in both of those worlds, right? >> That's right. >> Yeah, it's up to you to figure it out and the customer- >> Yeah. >> from a storage standpoint. Here it is, serve it up. >> And that's the thrust of this announcement, right? Is bringing together two great companies, the Dell platform, the Snowflake platform, and allowing organizations to bring that together. And they decide like it, as we all know, customers decide how they're going to build their architecture. And so this is just another way that we're helping them leverage the capabilities of our two great platforms. >> Does this push or pull or little bit of both? I mean, where'd this come from? Or customers saying, "Hey, it would be kind of cool if we could have this." Or is it more, "Hey, what do you guys think?" You know, where are you at with that? >> It was definitely both, right? I mean, so we certainly started with, you know, a high level idea that, you know, the technologies are complimentary, right? I mean, as Clark just described, and at the same time we had customers coming to us saying, "Hey, wait a minute, I'm doing this over here, and this over here, how can I make this easier?" So that was like I said, we started with a blank sheet and lots of long customer conversations and this is what resulted. So >> So what are the sequence of events to kind of roll this out? You said it's second half, you know, when do you start getting customers involved? Do you have your already, you know, to poke at this and what's that look like? >> Yeah, sure. I can weigh in there. So, absolutely. We've had a few of our big customers that have been involved sort of in the design already who understand how they want to use it. So I think our expectation is that now that the sort of demonstrations have been in place, we have some pre functionality, we're going to see some initial testing and usage, some beta type situations with our customers. And then second half, we'll ramp from there. >> It's got to be a huge overlap between Dell customers and Snowflake customers. I mean, it's hundred billion. You can't not bump into Dell somewhere. >> Exactly. Yeah, you know. >> So where do you guys want to see this relationship go, kind of how should we measure success? Maybe you could each give your perspectives of that. >> I mean, for us, I think it's really showing the value of the Snowflake platform in this new world where there's a whole new ecosystem of data that is accessible to us, right? So seeing those organizations that are saying like, "Look, I'm doing new things with on-premises data that I didn't think that I could do before", or, "I'm driving efficiency in how I do analytics, and data engineering, and data science, in ways that I couldn't do before," 'cause they were locked out of using a Snowflake-like technology, right? So I think for me, that's going to be that real excitement. I'm really curious to see how the collaboration and the sharing component comes into this, you know, where you can think of having an on-premises data strategy and a need, right? But you can really connect to Cloud native customers and partners and suppliers that live in the Snowflake ecosystem, and that wasn't possible before. And so that is very conceivable and very possible through this relationship. So seeing how those edges get created in in our world and how people start to collaborate across data, both in the Cloud and on-prem is going to be really exciting. >> I remember I asked Frank, it was kind of early in the pandemic. I asked him, come on, tell me about how you're managing things. And he was awesome. And I asked him to at the time, you know, "You're ever going to do, you know, bring this platform on-prem?" He's like unequivocal, "No way, that's never going to happen. We're not going to do it halfway house ware Cloud only." And I kept thinking, but there's got to be a way to expand that team. There's so much data out there, and so boom, now we see the answer . Martin, from your standpoint, what does success look like? >> I think it starts with our partnership, right? So I've been doing this a long time. Probably the first time I've worked so closely with a partner like Snowflake. Joint customer conversations, joint solutioning, making sure what we're building is going to be really, truly as useful as possible to them. And I think we're going to let them guide us as we go forward here, right? You mentioned, you know, systems or record or other potential platforms. We're going to let them tell us where exactly the most value will come from the integration between the two companies. >> Yeah. Follow data. I mean, remember in the old days a hardware company like Dell would go to an ISP like Snowflake and say, "Hey, we ran some benchmarks. Your software runs really fast on our hardware, can we work together?" And you go, "Yeah, of course. Yeah, no problem." But wow! What a different dynamic it is today. >> Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. >> All right guys. Hey, thanks so much for coming to theCube. It's great to see you. We'll see you at the Snowflake Summit in June. >> Snowflake Summit in a month and a half. >> Looking forward to that. All right. Thank you again. >> Thank you Dave. >> All right. Keep it right there everybody. This is Dave Vellante, wall to wall coverage of Dell Tech World 2022. We'll be right back. (gentle music)

>> theCube presents Dell Technologies World, brought to you by Dell. >> Hi everyone, welcome back to Dell Technologies World 2022. You're watching theCube's coverage of this, three-day coverage wall to wall. My name is David Vellante John Furrier's here, Lisa Martin, David Nicholson. Talk of the town here is data. And one of the big announcements at the show is Snowflake and Dell partnering up, building ecosystems. Snowflake reaching into on-prem, allowing customers to actually access the Snowflake Data Cloud without moving the data or if they want to move the data they can. This is really one of the hotter announcements of the show. Martin Glynn is here, he's the Senior Director of Storage Product Management at Dell Technologies. And Clark Patterson, he's the Head of Product Marketing for Snowflake. Guys, welcome. >> Thanks for having us. >> So a lot of buzz around this and, you know, Clark, you and I have talked about the need to really extend your data vision. And this really is the first step ever you've taken on-prem. Explain the motivation for this from your customer's perspective. >> Yeah. I mean, if you step back and think about Snowflake's vision and our mission of mobilizing the world's data, it's all around trying to break down silos for however customers define what a silo is, right? So we've had a lot of success breaking down silos from a workload perspective where we've expanded the platform to be data warehousing, and data engineering, and machine learning, and data science, and all the kind of compute intensive ways that people work with us. We've also had a lot of success in our sharing capabilities and how we're breaking down silos of organizations, right? So I can share data more seamlessly within my team, I can do it across totally disparate organizations, and break down silos that way. So this partnership is really like the next leg of the stool, so to speak, where we're breaking down the silos of the the data and where the data lives ultimately, right? So up until this point, Cloud, all focus there, and now we have this opportunity with Dell to expand that and into on-premises world and people can bring all those data sets together. >> And the data target for this Martin, is Dell ECS, right? Your object store, and it's got S3 compatibility. Explain that. >> Yeah, we've actually got sort of two flavors. We'll start with ECS, which is our turnkey object storage solution. Object storage offers sort of the ultimate in flexibility, you know, potential performance, ease of use, right? Which is why it fits so well with Snowflake's mission for sort of unlocking, you know, the data within the data center. So we'll offer it to begin with ECS, and then we also recently announced our software defined object scale solution. So add even more flexibility there. >> Okay. And the clock, the way it works is I can now access non-native Snowflake data using what? Materialized views, external tables, how does that work? >> Some combination of all the above. So we've had in Snowflake a capability called external tables which we refer to, it goes hand in hand with this notion of external stages. Basically through the combination of those two capabilities, it's a metadata layer on data wherever it resides. So customers have actually used this in Snowflake for data lake data outside of Snowflake in the Cloud up until this point. So it's effectively an extension of that functionality into the Dell on-premises world, so that we can tap into those things. So we use the external stages to expose all the metadata about what's in the Dell environment. And then we build external tables in Snowflake so that data looks like it is in Snowflake. And then the experience for the analyst or whomever it is, is exactly as though that data lives in the Snowflake world. >> Okay. So for a while you've allowed non-native Snowflake data but it had to be in the Cloud. >> Correct. >> It was the first time it's on-prem, >> that's correct >> that's the innovation here. Okay. And if I want to bring it into the Cloud, can I? >> Yeah, the connection here will help in a migration sense as well, right? So that's the good thing is, it's really giving the user the choice. So we are integrating together as partners to make connection as seamless as possible. And then the end user will say like, look I've got data that needs to live on-premises, for whatever reasons, data sovereignty whatever they decide. And they can keep it there and still do the analytics in another place. But if there's a need and a desire to use this as an opportunity to migrate some of that data to Cloud, that connection between our two platforms will make that easier. >> Well, Michael always says, "Hey, it's customer choice, we're flexible." So you're cool with that? That's been the mission since we kind of came together, right? Is if our customers needed to stay in their data center, if that makes more sense from a cost perspective or, you know, a data gravity perspective, then they can do that. But we also want to help them unlock the value of that data. So if they need to copy it up to the public Cloud and take advantage of it, we're going to integrate directly with Snowflake to make that really easy to do. >> So there are engineering integrations here, obviously that's required. Can you describe what that looks like? Give us the details on when it's available. >> Sure. So it's going to be sort of second half this year that you'll see, we're demoing it this week, but the availability we second half this year. And fundamentally, it's the way Clark described it, that Snowflake will reach into our S3 interface using the standard S3 interface. We're qualifying between the way they expect that S3 interface to present the data and the way our platform works, just to ensure that there's smooth interaction between the two. So that's sort of the first simplest use case. And then the second example we gave where the customer can copy some of that data up to the public Cloud. We're basically copying between two S3 buckets and making sure that Snowflake's Snowpipe is aware that data's being made available and can easily ingest it. >> And then that just goes into a virtual warehouse- >> Exactly. >> and customer does to know or care. >> Yep Exactly. >> Yeah. >> The compute happens in Snowflake the way it does in any other manner. >> And I know you got to crawl, walk, run second half of this year, but I would imagine, okay, you're going to start with AWS, correct? And then eventually you go to other Clouds. I mean, that's going to take other technical integrations, I mean, obviously. So should we assume there's a roadmap here or is this a one and done? >> I would assume that, I mean, based on our multi-Cloud approach, that's kind of our approach at least, yeah. >> Kind of makes sense, right? I mean, that would seem to be a natural progression. My other thought was, okay, I've got operational systems. They might be transaction systems running on a on a PowerMax. >> Yeah. >> Is there a way to get the data into an object store and make that available, now that opens up even more workloads. I know you're not committing to doing that, but it just, conceptually, it seems like something a customer might want to do. >> Yeah. I, a hundred percent, agree. I mean, I think when we brought our team together we started with a blank slate. It was what's the best solution we can build. We landed on this sort of first step, but we got lots of feedback from a lot of our big joint customers about you know, this system over there, this potential integration over here, and whether it's, you know, PowerMax type systems or other file workloads with native Snowflake data types. You know, I think this is just the beginning, right? We have lots of potential here. >> And I don't think you've announced pricing, right? It's premature for that. But have you thought about, and how are you thinking about the pricing model? I mean, you're a consumption based pricing, is that kind of how this is going to work? Or is it a sort of a new pricing model or haven't you figured that out yet? >> I don't know if you've got any details on that, but from a Snowflake perspective, I would assume it's consistent with how our customers engage with us today. >> Yeah. >> And we'll offer both possibilities, right? So you can either continue with the standard, you know, sort of CapEx motion, maybe that's the most optimal for you from a cost perspective, or you can take advantage through our OpEx option, right? So you can do consumption on-prem also. >> Okay. So it could be a dual model, right? Depending on what the customer wants. If they're a Snowflake customer, obviously it's going to be consumption based, however, you guys price. What's happening, Clark, in in the market? Explain why Snowflake has so much momentum and, you know, traction in the marketplace. >> So like I spent a lot of time doing analysis on why we win and lose, core part of my role. And, you know, there's a couple of, there's really three things that come up consistently as to why people people are really excited about Snowflake platform. One is the most simplest thing of all. It feels like is just ease of use and it just works, right? And I think the way that this platform was built for the Cloud from the ground up all the way back 10 years ago, really a lot allows us to deliver that seamless experience of just like instant compute when you want it, it goes away, you know, only pay for what you use. Very few knobs to turn and things like that. And so people absolutely love that factor. The other is multi-Cloud. So, you know, there's definitely a lot of organizations out there that have a multi-Cloud strategy, and, you know, what that means to them can be highly variable, but regardless, they want to be able to interact across Clouds in some capacity. And of course we are a single platform, like literally one single interface, consistent across all the three Cloud providers that we work upon. And it gives them that flexibility to mix and match Cloud infrastructure under any Snowflake however they see fit. The last piece of it is sharing. And, you know, I think it's that ability as I kind of alluded to around like breaking down organizational silos, and allow people to be able to actually connect with each other in ways that you couldn't do before. Like, if you think about how you and I would've shared data before, I'd be like, "Hey, Dave, I'm going to unload this table into a spreadsheet and I'm going to send it over in email." And there's the whole host of issues that get introduced in that and world, now it's like instantly available. I have a lot of control over it, it's governed it's all these other things. And I can create kind of walled gardens, so to speak, of how far out I want that to go. It could be in a controlled environment of organizations that I want to collaborate with, or I can put it on our marketplace and expose it to the whole world, because I think there's a value in that. And if I choose I can monetize it, right? So those, you know, the ease of use aspect of it, absolutely, it's just a fantastic platform. The multi-Cloud aspect of it and our unique differentiation around sharing in our marketplace and monetization. >> Yeah, on the sharing front. I mean, it's now discoverable. Like if you send me an email, like what'd you call that? When did you send that email? And then the same time I can forward that to somebody else's not governed. >> Yeah. >> All right. So that just be creates a nightmare for the compliance. >> Right. Yeah. You think about how you revoke access in that situation. You just don't, right? Now I can just turn it off and you go in to run your query. >> Don't get access on that data anymore. Yeah. Okay. And then the other thing I wanted to ask you, Clark is Snowflake started really as analytics platform, simplifying data warehousing, you're moving into that world of data science, you know, the whole data lake movement, bringing those two worlds together. You know, I was talking to Ben Ward about this, maybe there's a semantic layer that helps us kind of talk between those two worlds, but you don't care, right? If it's in an object store, it can play in both of those worlds, right? >> That's right. >> Yeah, it's up to you to figure it out and the customer- >> Yeah. >> from a storage standpoint. Here it is, serve it up. >> And that's the thrust of this announcement, right? Is bringing together two great companies, the Dell platform, the Snowflake platform, and allowing organizations to bring that together. And they decide like it, as we all know, customers decide how they're going to build their architecture. And so this is just another way that we're helping them leverage the capabilities of our two great platforms. >> Does this push or pull or little bit of both? I mean, where'd this come from? Or customers saying, "Hey, it would be kind of cool if we could have this." Or is it more, "Hey, what do you guys think?" You know, where are you at with that? >> It was definitely both, right? I mean, so we certainly started with, you know, a high level idea that, you know, the technologies are complimentary, right? I mean, as Clark just described, and at the same time we had customers coming to us saying, "Hey, wait a minute, I'm doing this over here, and this over here, how can I make this easier?" So that was like I said, we started with a blank sheet and lots of long customer conversations and this is what resulted. So >> So what are the sequence of events to kind of roll this out? You said it's second half, you know, when do you start getting customers involved? Do you have your already, you know, to poke at this and what's that look like? >> Yeah, sure. I can weigh in there. So, absolutely. We've had a few of our big customers that have been involved sort of in the design already who understand how they want to use it. So I think our expectation is that now that the sort of demonstrations have been in place, we have some pre functionality, we're going to see some initial testing and usage, some beta type situations with our customers. And then second half, we'll ramp from there. >> It's got to be a huge overlap between Dell customers and Snowflake customers. I mean, it's hundred billion. You can't not bump into Dell somewhere. >> Exactly. Yeah, you know. >> So where do you guys want to see this relationship go, kind of how should we measure success? Maybe you could each give your perspectives of that. >> I mean, for us, I think it's really showing the value of the Snowflake platform in this new world where there's a whole new ecosystem of data that is accessible to us, right? So seeing those organizations that are saying like, "Look, I'm doing new things with on-premises data that I didn't think that I could do before", or, "I'm driving efficiency in how I do analytics, and data engineering, and data science, in ways that I couldn't do before," 'cause they were locked out of using a Snowflake-like technology, right? So I think for me, that's going to be that real excitement. I'm really curious to see how the collaboration and the sharing component comes into this, you know, where you can think of having an on-premises data strategy and a need, right? But you can really connect to Cloud native customers and partners and suppliers that live in the Snowflake ecosystem, and that wasn't possible before. And so that is very conceivable and very possible through this relationship. So seeing how those edges get created in in our world and how people start to collaborate across data, both in the Cloud and on-prem is going to be really exciting. >> I remember I asked Frank, it was kind of early in the pandemic. I asked him, come on, tell me about how you're managing things. And he was awesome. And I asked him to at the time, you know, "You're ever going to do, you know, bring this platform on-prem?" He's like unequivocal, "No way, that's never going to happen. We're not going to do it halfway house ware Cloud only." And I kept thinking, but there's got to be a way to expand that team. There's so much data out there, and so boom, now we see the answer . Martin, from your standpoint, what does success look like? >> I think it starts with our partnership, right? So I've been doing this a long time. Probably the first time I've worked so closely with a partner like Snowflake. Joint customer conversations, joint solutioning, making sure what we're building is going to be really, truly as useful as possible to them. And I think we're going to let them guide us as we go forward here, right? You mentioned, you know, systems or record or other potential platforms. We're going to let them tell us where exactly the most value will come from the integration between the two companies. >> Yeah. Follow data. I mean, remember in the old days a hardware company like Dell would go to an ISP like Snowflake and say, "Hey, we ran some benchmarks. Your software runs really fast on our hardware, can we work together?" And you go, "Yeah, of course. Yeah, no problem." But wow! What a different dynamic it is today. >> Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. >> All right guys. Hey, thanks so much for coming to theCube. It's great to see you. We'll see you at the Snowflake Summit in June. >> Snowflake Summit in a month and a half. >> Looking forward to that. All right. Thank you again. >> Thank you Dave. >> All right. Keep it right there everybody. This is Dave Vellante, wall to wall coverage of Dell Tech World 2022. We'll be right back. (gentle music)