>> live from Boston, Massachusetts. It's the you covering your red hat. Some twenty nineteen >> rots. >> You buy bread >> hat, >> and we'LL go back here on the Cube as we continue our coverage here. Red Hat Summit day. One of three days of Walter Wall coverage coming to you exclusively here on the Q. I'm John Walls was too Millman. Thank you for joining us. And we're now joined by a couple of gentlemen. Guess the dynamic duo of the container World it at Red Hat. Scott McCarty is the principal product manager of Containers. That open shift and Forell. Scott. Good to see you, sir. >> You could see it >> and been. Bree are Who's the principal product? Manager of Containers and Koro s, Of course. Also it Red hat Been. Thank you for joining us. First off, just your thought about show. Obviously, there's a lot of educational programming going on up down, big crowds, a lot of buzz. Good activity day one, at least from our perspective. How are you guys seeing this so far? >> I love it. I mean, it's been great so far. We just had us. I just had a session, just got out of it. was completely full of people trying to get in that were lined up against a wall. So it's been very exciting so far. >> Yeah. Ben. So it's one of >> my favorite times of the year, right? It's so much energy. Everybody comes with the exchange of ideas, just feedback and everything is one of my favorites. >> Oh, good. Right now s o l e made available publicly today for the first time. We talked about that a lot so far on the program, I'd like to hear from >> your side of the fence. Then what does that mean to you in terms of the container world and the impact that you, you know, from here going forward, you've got a whole new world of concern, I would think Scott. >> Yeah. I mean, with the relic, it's it's >> exciting because we're releasing, uh, you know, a lot of new tools around containers, >> a ton of new operational, you know, management capabilities. I mean, it's just it's an exciting release, Ben. It's a It's a big step forward, right? Every single release is a big deal, and we look at the container space. It's evolved a lot in the past for five years right when we came out. Seven. So technology's matured, Really, it's Ah, it's a smooth, easy experience to get to the release. And if lots going into it a lot, >> Yeah, so, Scott, It's funny. I think back. Turn back. Five years ago, we had a lot of jokes about doctors. You mean the pants? Because container ization and, you know, limits, containers and everything. That was something most people hadn't heard about here. Twenty nineteen, You said, There's, you know, crowds trying to get in the door. And it's not what but there really digging in and understand the tools we give a little bit of. You know what? What's what's with the excitement these days? Where are the customers? And you know what? What do you digging into >> with them? Yeah, well ah, >> funny example. So I asked I asked this last session, You know, raise your hand if you've used containers. If you just even fired up a container before and everyone raise your hand. And now, five years ago, that was, like one person >> and then even last you worked for Google. Yeah. Even last >> year that it was still maybe forty percent of the people, and now it's one hundred percent when they come to a session. So I mean, it's it is it is definitely changed, a tremendous amount. And now it's about So I joked, You know, five years ago is about using a chef knife, you know, just like you cut everything with it, right? You cut it. Vegetables, meat, whatever. And there was like one thing, and you just figured out Doctor and Cooper names was even on the radar Yet now it's about refining all the tools and getting to a place where, like, it's really getting excited, cause now we have special paring knives and chef knife and, you know, hibachi, knife and all these different, more specialized >> tools. So it's getting saying >> You think it's easy to >> adopt now to write, because years ago everyone was hedging their bets on you know what orchestration am I going to use? What piece? Um, I'm gonna build my stack. We have >> now. It's much, much clear, well defined. You know, Cooper Netease is dominant factor, right? Mean, open shift is huge, huge growth for us in that space. So I mean, it's it's it's a lot easier for customers to get in that game now than it was, you know? Yeah, just a couple years ago. Yeah, just a couple years ago. All right, so let's let's sticking out security a little bit because that was one of the big question marks in the early days. And you know something? We talk about it all the shows. It's it's definitely a focus of the real late launch. So where were the container world today and anything new or nuance that the audience should understand? I think on the security side you've got I have three or four big points there. One is the container tools of worshipping. Today they basically inherit the full Lennox security model. Right? So no longer do you have ah, privilege socket. That is, I kind of that weak factor, if you will, that's gone on. Really? So that's a big That's a big win right there. Beyond that, we've got a new crystal policies. You can set a central policy for the O. S. And that works in the containers well, so of you and enforce a particular kind of floor, if you will, of crypto. You could do that with relate for the host way and images as well. That's a that's a big part of it. And then we also have new tools that you can build smaller containers because how did the security is what is in my container? So if you're putting less less packages and content in that image, that's a much smaller Becker as well. Soon. >> Yeah. So, um, from from a security perspective, too, you know, you know the fact that now we have, um, kind of we've got a set of tools now that we can do experiments with things like ruthless, for example. You know, we're tech preview release of ruthless contract, so historically have always ran them, you know, as route. That's just how it works. I mean, we kind of figured it out one way and did it, and it was cool. And then at a certain point, we went all right, we need these other use cases where want developers to build to do it. For example, I just talked to a customer that it has four two hundred. I'm sorry, developers that are all running instances on their laptops PM's with pod man and build a running and, you know, using these tools to actually build containers, and they want to do ruthless bad. They want to do it in all their essentially all their environment, so that people are really hungry for a lot of these security features that we're working on now and relate. And it's something that we're releasing even as a vato. >> How did the capabilities changed in terms of relate now and what you have to provide the support? So what's transformed? And then what will be the need in order to build on that toe work on that and to make it more secure stables on so >> far? Well, I think I think you kind of have to dig into, like, a selection of what tools we decided to go in. Relate you'LL see that it's pod man. Build a scope. Here are the three main lower level tools that we have, and those tools are built serving a Unix mindset where it's like you can pipe things together and do things and use them collaboratively together to go remotely inspect images, pull them, build them from scratch, you know, run them locally, not as roots run them as a non route, contains things like that way or not at, you know, we're not releasing doctrine. Relate. And so so the transition. There is probably the biggest transition for users. Kind of realizing. Okay, we're going kind of broken this apart into three little or tools that we can then use Todd Man being the main one you go to. And then and then it's got a command line that's very similar. And so it's very easy, tio kind of transition over. But then you start to again kind of my my chef knife reference. You realize once you transition from, say, Dr Pod man, you kind of that's your chef knife. You kind of know what? How to start doing things that way. But then you start to get more refined and start to dig deeper into, you know, like, you know, into building scope. You essentially teacher. Yeah. >> You're good there. Yeah. I don't know. All right. Whatever he says. Scott >> Universal base image. Something we've talked a little bit about to tell us how that this is going to impact, you know, talk about everybody building things on their laptop. Seems like that's an extension of where this fits. Help help us understand? >> Yeah, I can't hide my enthusiasm. One how excited I am by Eva, and I will admit Ivory had a couple people come to me and say, This is the most exciting thing for me at Summit period And I think that's interesting because it's not actually something new and that, you would say from a technology perspective, how exciting is that? I don't know, but like it allows a set of collaboration that we've never been able to like, really, really do with a well base image historically, and I think the real base image is the highest quality basement temperament out there. But the problem is, even if you had something really simple, like so you had one university and that created some kind of science experiment in a container, and then they want to push that out to a public registry, then pull it down a different university and share it. They couldn't do that under the terms of the rail base image. So that was that. Was that create a little bit of friction with the FBI? Now that's completely gone. You can now run it anywhere you want, distribute anywhere you want, just the distribution alone is exciting. It and the fact that when you >> run it on rail, you >> build on rail, run on relics completely supported Israel. But you can now push it out to a public registry and let it sit out there and other people can >> use it in an experiment. So is the, you know, coming together of container ization in that distribution is that would kind of is really new with this, as opposed to the ways that I used to be able to share lennox images in the past. >> Well, all I think I think the challenge was you'd have some people that would want to do something. They want to build a distributed anywhere they want have that freedom. But they still wanted the quality of the rail basement. Now that created friction, right? So then they'd have to make an unnatural choice between, like, a fedora or I use, you know, well, maybe how you sent to less and your lying and none of those have all the things that I want, right? It was like a card game trying to get all the components that you want. You want sport, ability of Raoul. You want the security of the performance center center. But you couldn't. You couldn't distribute anywhere, so that created friction where you make on natural choices on basement. Now you be. I just The name implies that universal use it for anything you want. >> Same for communities to write because they don't want to make one that could freely distribute and then another like supported variant. They have more to maintain its more cycles and everything so simple. Find that it is a big deal. Yeah, >> and migration between base images is a linen migration, so it's frustrating to do. You don't want to do it. You want to build on one thing. And then I thought I distribute that thing anywhere. Well, then it's >> interesting, you know, go back a few years. There was this big movement to do, like just enough OS. How do I slim down the core? Os was I don't need everything that you know Realm necessarily does. So have we gotten over that? And we now gotten with you know, the things like you be I down to like a nice unit that's easily terrible and distributed. It's a good question. It's a topic that we'LL never go away. I don't think we're still. It's just changing its form, right? It still exists on the host. It's still exists in images. It's still exist with unit colonels and everything. I >> think where we >> are today. That was a really good spot, right? We've got several footprints of FBI. If there's several footprints of Rehl, including well, Core OS, which is like bedded version of rail into open shift right for a small form factor container host. So where we are today is very strong, but it's going to continue to evolve and get better. So, yeah, >> and we I mean, we look at the future and we're we're looking at ways toe. Make it even smaller, you know, you're always looking at, but yeah, Ben, mention there's three footprints of you B i today. There's a minimal image. There's a standard image, and then there's even a little bit bigger images allows you run multiple services, but you know that's the selection today. But in the future, we're looking at making the minimal one more minimal. Were even looking at, you know, making the standard one more minimal. >> Yeah, we're not done. Yeah, we're not done. You're never done. I guess the last thing I have on this, you know, multi cloud is such you know where customers are today. You know, you're gonna have the CEO Microsoft up on stage today. Two years ago, when I was here, it was the partnership between Red had an eight of us was all the discussion. I spoke to the Red Hat team, the Cloud show recently. So how does the tooling that you have fit in tow all the clouds discussion that I have when I talked to users? You know, one of the biggest lock ins they have is the skill set and the understanding of different tools and knowledge. And so you know, where we standardize and where do we still have work to do in this space? That's a big question. So yeah, I guess way addressing a multiple levels right at the core. The center Israel. Right. So well ate right now today on all those cloud platforms that you just name, right. So same say maybe I level guarantee that ten years hard work everything. It's it's everywhere. It's pervasive today. Level up, right. You've got the container images and stuff same story. They're Goa level. You've got open shift that is pervasive everywhere. And now we're doing really cool things. And Cooper Net. He's like a machine, a p I and all these other things toe actually control those individual cloud infrastructures which abstracts all of the customers ations per for food for him, which is >> powerful. So I think, for me was the most exciting things is the open shift for paradigm shift that shift from managing individual nodes to ship to managing the cluster as a computer, which we've said for what, twenty years? The sun? I think you know the cluster is the computer, you know? But we're really there today. Like we have a single E p I. Ben mention the machine, the machine, a PR machine configure operator. There's there's essentially automation built into the chip platform now that allows you to appoint the same on any cloud. So eight of us azure, you know, open stack, even on VM, where even on, you know, even in liver gonna look a laptop. There's a way to deploy it in the identical, you know, in an identical configuration. To me, that's exciting, because now I have one set of things I could learn. And then again in the standard red hat way. If you feel locked in, you can go use a Okay, Daddy, you can use the upstream. So you're never locked into our product, Which that's something. Get a lot with Kat drives, right? Like if you're locked in there, you're you're locked in there. There's no there's no, you know, open source version of that to get out of that. >> So you've talked about growth opportunities? You said, No, we're not done yet. Making the joke about your own work. You've talked about a twenty year evolution, you know, Just refer to that. And if you could look, you know, whether it's three, four, five, whatever years down the road, where's the big leap? Where's that have to come? Where do you think it's going to come in terms of the capabilities that you want to work on and what you want to be able to deliver from where you are right? Now >> get my crystal ball. Yeah. >> Yeah, Well, I think you've got one. Yeah. Then I have a lot of confidence in you, but if you had to say okay, this is this is atleast where we're gonna be. We're gonna have to spend a lot of our time because this this is the area that we think I think needs most attention. A >> couple of things, right? People only scale so much. So automation is an area that's bulletproof going forward, and it's going to evolve and take many forms. Right now, our big push has been on the operator space and obviously technologies like answerable that's going to continue to evolve and make make people scale better. That's probably one of the biggest ones. And I >> think that's one of the biggest ones. I think I think for me, probably where my mind wanders, is around partners and building that ecosystem in the open ship space similar to what you see in the realm. Because system today I think three, four years from now you're going to see it really exploded at ABC that I already see it exploding. But by then you'LL see it maturing and you'LL really see. I think if you look at the operator paradigm, I'm very excited by that because it's kind of like the Emma science dollar that Microsoft invented. You know that kind of made that that ubiquitous that install experience. Except that operators make it you because they install and managed a too. So I think, like, kind of to his point of, like making that the install really simple and then the operation of it. Over time, I think you're going to see a lot of I think. I think you couldn't fill a room and ask him, Like what I in fact, I did. I asked what an operator was, you know, and they they weren't super aware of it yet. But I think in the next five years, that will become the big with this way of just installing software. >> All right, well, we're going to check back in five. We'LL see how it turns out and been by then. Bring that crystal ball back with wood. Ok, I'll do a good deal. Thanks, gentlemen. Thanks for the time you haven't put on the Cuba as we continue our coverage here. Red Hat Summit. We're in Boston back with more right after this